July 10 (Reuters) - It's hard to overstate the stakes
for the lawyers who persuaded a Delaware judge to void Tesla
founder's Elon Musk's $56 billion pay package.
The size of the legal fee they are requesting is undoubtedly
vast: more than 29 million Tesla shares, valued at $7.74 billion
as of Thursday morning's market opening. And so is the gulf
between that sum and what Tesla - and many of its investors -
think the lawyers may actually deserve for their work on behalf
of a lone shareholder client.
"No one has identified a single instance of lawyers
collecting that kind of money for a lawsuit. Ever," Tesla argued
in court papers ahead of a hearing on the fee earlier this week.
The car marker is asking instead for a fee award as low as
$13.6 million for the plaintiff's lawyers at Bernstein Litowitz
Berger & Grossmann, Andrews & Springer, and Friedman Oster &
Tejtel. The firms in January persuaded Chancellor Kathaleen
McCormick to void Musk's pay package, although the lawyers are
still arguing about the effects of that ruling.
The lawyers' fee request is about 25 times what Tesla
identified as the record in Delaware - $304 million in attorney
fees approved 2011 in shareholder litigation involving the
Southern Peru Copper Corp.
Bernstein Litowitz's Greg Varallo declined to comment. He
argued during the hearing this week that a large award would
encourage attorneys to protect small investors. He said
McCormick's judgment was the largest ever by an American court,
and that the 11% share they are seeking is fair.
Lawyers for Tesla and Varallo's co-counsel at Andrews &
Springer and Friedman Oster & Tejtel did not immediately respond
to a request for comment. McCormick's ruling could take weeks or
months.
The size of the fee request is also a moving target. Tesla's
fluctuating share price means the size of the fee bid grew by
$300 million just in the days since the lawyers met in Delaware
to argue about it on Monday.
It grew by about $2.3 billion since mid-June, when Tesla
shareholders thumbed their nose at the Delaware court by voting
to approve Musk's pay package and move the company's legal home
to Texas.
More than 8,000 Tesla stockholders have flooded the court
with some 1,500 letters and objections over the fee, according
to case documents.
If awarded, the requested fees at their current value would
amount to more than $390,000 for every hour worked by the 37
lawyers, associates and paralegals who litigated the case on
behalf of Richard Tornetta, a former heavy metal drummer who
owned just nine shares of Tesla when he sued, court documents
showed.
It would not only dwarf past awards in Delaware. Outside the
state, the biggest fee in a shareholder case was $688 million in
awarded in 2008 for the legal team that obtained a $7.2 billion
settlement in the Enron securities fraud case in Texas federal
court.
The most recent $500 million-plus fee award came in an
antitrust class action, when a judge approved $667 million for
the plaintiffs firms that negotiated a $2.67 billion settlement
with Blue Cross Blue Shield over insurance charges.
The lawyers behind the Blue Cross Blue Shield case at Boies
Schiller Flexner, Hausfeld and other firms cleared a final
hurdle in June, when the U.S. Supreme Court declined to take up
the last appeal over the deal.
- In other legal fee news, an attorney known for filing hundreds
of food and beverage labeling lawsuits must pay the legal fees
of retailer Big Lots, which was accused of selling coffee with
misleading labels.
A federal judge in Florida last week sanctioned Spencer
Sheehan after finding he "flagrantly disregarded" the court's
rules by actively participating in the case without seeking
permission as an out-of-state lawyer. The amount in fees and
costs Sheehan will have to pay has been not determined yet.
(Legal Fee Tracker is a weekly feature exploring attorney
compensation awards and disputes in class actions, bankruptcies
and other matters. Please send tips or suggestions to
READ MORE:
Legal Fee Tracker: Lawyers' $170 million payday in limbo in
credit card swipe fee case
Legal Fee Tracker: Lawyer's 4,000 hours help Sullivan &
Cromwell reach $200 mln mark in FTX case