financetom
Economy
financetom
/
Economy
/
Jobs report will offer fresh test of Fed Chairman Warsh's less-guidance stance
News World Market Environment Technology Personal Finance Politics Retail Business Economy Cryptocurrency Forex Stocks Market Commodities
Jobs report will offer fresh test of Fed Chairman Warsh's less-guidance stance
Aug 10, 2026 6:52 AM

(In Aug 7 story, corrects company name in paragraph 13)

By Karen Brettell

Aug 7 (Reuters) - Federal Reserve Chairman Kevin Warsh wants the bond market to take the wheel, contending it should do more of the work of setting the price of money in America.

In the seven weeks since his debut policy meeting as chairman, the result has been a volatile, expensive test of a long dormant economic argument: at what point does information from the central bank become too much information for monetary policy to work efficiently? And how will investors react to economic data and other developments with less guidance from the Fed than they have become accustomed to in recent years?

The latest response to this question will come on Friday morning with the release of the July employment report, a key read on an economy that many investors believe is already running hot.

The price of Warsh's communications-policy shift became unmistakable at his press conference following the Fed's most recent policy meeting last week. A rate hold was expected - futures markets saw only a one-in-three chance of a hike - but what rattled investors was the absence of any clear marker for what would come next.

Longer-dated Treasury yields quickly rose, with the 30-year yield hitting its highest level since 2007 and the 10-year yield touching a level last seen in January 2025.

Oil prices spiked heading into the Fed meeting, thanks to the ebb and flow of the Iran war, renewing questions about Warsh's inflation-fighting resolve. Yields have since declined modestly alongside oil prices, but for many investors the question of how the communications shift will play out in markets is far from settled.

"There is a tension between what Warsh wants versus what the market wants," said Bill Campbell, portfolio manager and head of global sovereign and emerging markets at DoubleLine Capital. Investors now must infer from limited guidance what the Fed chair once spelled out: how the Fed would respond to incoming data.

WHAT "LESS GUIDANCE" MEANS

Forward guidance, the Fed's signaling on likely rate paths, became standard after 2008, when rates hit zero and policymakers used future promises to push down long-term borrowing costs.

Chris Low, chief economist at FHN Financial, said the tool worked as intended then. But the habit grew under Jerome Powell, who rarely moved rates without first telegraphing it. This, Low said, can tie the Fed's hands when quicker action is warranted.

Markets have fixated on the Fed's "dot plot" rate forecasts - projections that often miss the mark as shifting data reshapes the outlook.

Warsh argues the Fed is no better than markets at forecasting the future, so its decisions should look backward, not forward - with the "transitory" inflation call after the pandemic a case in point.

For some investors, the ambiguity is the point. "The strategy behind pulling back on forward guidance is forcing the market to take responsibility and enlisting the market in helping him do his job," said Thomas Urano, co-chief investment officer at Sage Advisory.

Robert Tipp, chief investment strategist and head of global bonds at PGIM, says less certainty from the Fed forces investors to price risk themselves rather than lean on Fed promises.

He points to the prior hiking cycle as a cautionary tale, when Powell routinely talked down the rate outlook even while raising rates, softening the tightening he sought. "You need to make it more expensive and a little more uncertain," Tipp said.

The strategy is a harder sell with inflation elevated, though. Low notes that Warsh made the case for stepping back and letting the market find its own equilibrium when the Fed is close to reaching its goals - back when inflation was under 3% and falling. It's closer to 4% now, which Low sees as the source of much of the criticism aimed at Warsh's approach.

A PREMIUM FOR UNCERTAINTY

Lou Brien, a market strategist at DRW Trading, argues markets aren't refusing the job Warsh has handed them - they're pricing what it costs to do it without a map. "The market wants to be compensated for it," he said, "and the way they get compensated is through higher interest rates."

Part of that premium, Brien argues, reflects lingering questions about Warsh's independence from the White House. Even setting that aside, Brien argues the Fed's influence doesn't vanish just because it stops explaining itself.

Investors still parse statements, dissents and press-conference answers for clues to its reaction function. "The Fed casts a shadow, like it or not," Brien said.

Others point out that other Fed policymakers are still offering their views even as Warsh stays quiet.

"The only one not providing forward guidance at the moment is Warsh," said Gennadiy Goldberg, head of U.S. rates strategy at TD Securities. "This is the era of contingent guidance because it's all contingent on the economic data."

For now, Warsh's approach hasn't resolved a key circularity, said Campbell. Warsh wants rates to be driven more by markets and data rather than the committee, while the market tries to divine his reaction function.

Meanwhile, Warsh has left the door open on this approach. As Low notes, "they're not necessarily committed to never using it again."

Comments
Welcome to financetom comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
Related Articles >
Fed's Bowman: Rate cuts will be needed if inflation keeps falling
Fed's Bowman: Rate cuts will be needed if inflation keeps falling
Aug 10, 2024
(Reuters) - Federal Reserve Governor Michelle Bowman softened her usually hawkish tone ever so slightly on Saturday, noting some further welcome progress on inflation in the last couple months even as she said inflation remains uncomfortably above the central bank's 2% goal and subject to upside risks. Should the incoming data continue to show that inflation is moving sustainably toward...
September Interest Rate Cut Still In The Cards Despite Inflation Rise
September Interest Rate Cut Still In The Cards Despite Inflation Rise
Aug 11, 2024
The Federal Reserve is likely to proceed with its expected interest-rate cut next month, despite a projected modest uptick in U.S. inflation in July. What Happened: Projections indicate that the consumer price index (CPI), due on Wednesday, will show a 0.2% increase from June for both the headline figure and the core gauge, which excludes food and energy. The annual...
Fed Likely to Deliver 50-Basis-Point Rate Cut Next Month Amid 'Market Worries,' ING Says
Fed Likely to Deliver 50-Basis-Point Rate Cut Next Month Amid 'Market Worries,' ING Says
Aug 9, 2024
02:00 PM EDT, 08/09/2024 (MT Newswires) -- The Federal Reserve is expected to lower its benchmark lending rate by half a percentage point next month, followed by a series of 25-basis-point cuts amid recent recession concerns and financial market turmoil, ING said Friday. Late last month, the central bank's Federal Open Market Committee left interest rates unchanged at 5.25% to...
Billionaire Tax, Interest Rate Cuts, And Trump's Take On Federal Reserve: This Week In Economics
Billionaire Tax, Interest Rate Cuts, And Trump's Take On Federal Reserve: This Week In Economics
Aug 11, 2024
The past week has been a whirlwind of financial news, with billionaires potentially facing a minimum tax, a call for swift interest rate cuts, and former President Donald Trump suggesting a say in Federal Reserve decisions. Elon Musk, Jeff Bezos, and Other Billionaires Could Face Minimum Tax Economist Gabriel Zucman, Professor of Economics at the Paris School of Economics and...
Copyright 2023-2026 - www.financetom.com All Rights Reserved