* Ex-military advisors predicted military action, aiding
financial firms
* Geopolitical risk analysis demand surges amid U.S.-Iran
tensions
* Investors seek updates on oil prices, shipping routes,
and conflict impact
* Financial industry merges national and economic
security strategies
* Investors moved into Treasuries despite inflation,
hinting at conflict anticipation
By Douglas Gillison, Gertrude Chavez-Dreyfuss and Michelle
Price
WASHINGTON/NEW YORK, March 12 (Reuters) - The day before
U.S.-Israeli air strikes killed Iran's Supreme Leader on
Saturday February 28, many Wall Street firms were expecting
military action thanks to a growing industry of ex-military and
national security advisors who were warning the signs were
clear.
Around 6 p.m. ET that Friday evening, for example,
geopolitical risk consultancy WestExec Advisors, advised
clients, which include big banks, that there was a 65%
probability of military action that weekend, said its managing
partner Nitin Chadda.
"It was clear to us that there was an intention to take some
meaningful Iran military action," said Chadda, adding the firm
had experienced an uptick in queries from financial clients and
had been helping some banks plan scenarios for how the conflict
may evolve.
A former senior Pentagon adviser, Chadda co-founded WestExec
in 2017 with others including Antony Blinken who became
Secretary of State in 2021. Its clients have included investment
bank Lazard ( LAZ ), private equity giant Blackstone, and Japan's
Softbank, according to 2021 media reports based on Blinken's
Senate disclosures at the time.
Demand for such geopolitical analysis surged as rising
U.S.-China tensions under President Trump's first administration
and the COVID-19 pandemic jolted supply chains and markets, and
continued growing with the war in Ukraine.
The recent Middle East conflict, which has sparked volatility in
stocks and bonds and a crisis in the oil market, has underscored
the importance of those investments, especially given Trump's
erratic foreign policy and propensity for U-turns.
Wall Street has been abuzz with briefings from ex-military
and national security experts as investors and companies
scramble for insight on issues ranging from Iran's stockpile of
mines to the knock-on effects of the conflict for semiconductor
manufacturing, said more than half a dozen other consultants,
banking sources and investors.
"What you're really seeing from the financial industry is how
national security and economic security have been merging over
the last few years, and that is accelerating," said Amy
Mitchell, founding partner at geopolitical consultancy Kilo
Alpha Strategies who was previously a senior Pentagon adviser.
LOOKING FOR 'TRIPWIRES'
The strikes followed a three-week round of U.S.-Iran
negotiations aimed at curbing the Islamic Republic's nuclear
ambitions during which Trump threatened to use force and the
U.S. massively boosted its military presence in the Gulf.
Negotiations wrapped up that Thursday with no sign of a
breakthrough, but Omani mediators said there had been progress
and that the two sides would resume talks in coming days.
Some doubted that would happen. While WestExec had no access
to U.S. war plans, executives there sensed growing frustration
from people close to the discussions, while other clues pointed
to an imminent strike, said Chadda.
Among them was what he characterized as a "last ditch"
Washington visit by Oman's foreign minister that Friday.
Chad Sweet, a former CIA officer and CEO of The Chertoff Group,
a global advisory firm with financial clients, said the arrival
of the USS Gerald R. Ford aircraft carrier in Israel early
Friday was another clear sign.
Others pointed to reports that the U.S. had allowed some embassy
staff in the region to leave.
"That was one of the final major trip wires," said Jay
Truesdale, CEO of TDI, a global advisor on geopolitical
strategy.
The firm had already explained to clients, including hedge
funds, traders, shippers, and industrials, that they should
monitor indications of potential government actions that reflect
the war plan, said Truesdale, adding such information is gleaned
from open sources.
"We knew that once the trip wires were triggered that the
likelihood of military action within 24-72 hours dramatically
increased."
Strange moves in U.S. Treasuries that Friday suggested some
investors were betting on those signs.
Despite surprisingly hot inflation data that would normally
drive investors to dump long-term Treasuries, traders were
moving in the opposite direction, pushing yields on the
benchmark 10-year Treasury note below 4%. Such a
sharp move into the safe-haven asset would usually be triggered
by an adverse macro event - or the strong belief that one was
imminent.
Tom di Galoma, managing director of global rates trading at
Mischler Financial, a boutique broker-dealer, said there was
talk in the market that the movements may have been prompted by
briefings from ex-military officials.
White House press secretary Karoline Leavitt said in an
email statement that Iran posed an imminent threat and the
strike was a courageous decision.
DEMAND FOR GEOPOLITICAL RISK ANALYSIS
Amid growing investor demand, JPMorgan ( JPM ), Bank of America ( BAC ), Lazard ( LAZ ),
Goldman Sachs ( GS ) and Deutsche Bank, among others, have launched
their own geopolitical advisory operations in recent years,
while others have invested in military and national security
expertise.
In November 2022, Deutsche said it had hired the late former
U.S. Secretary of State Henry Kissinger. Last year, Santander
hired the former head of the British Army General Sir Patrick
Sanders, to advise on its defense lending push.
Spokespeople for Deutsche Bank, JPMorgan ( JPM ) and Santander
declined to comment, while Goldman Sachs ( GS ) did not respond to a
request for comment. A BofA spokesperson said its geopolitical
department includes experienced national security and
intelligence analysts.
As the conflict widens, investors are seeking situational
updates, intelligence on shipping transit routes, the trajectory
for oil prices, and the impact of the crisis on energy-sensitive
industries, people said.
"It's been 24/7, fielding very specific questions from
clients across the spectrum, including investors and energy
folks," said Teddy Bunzel, head of Lazard's ( LAZ ) geopolitical
advisory business, which launched in 2022 and has several former
military advisors including retired four-star Admiral William
McRaven.
"Everyone is wondering - how does this end?"
(Additional reporting by Paritosh Bansal, Vidya Ranganathan,
Caroline Valetkevitch and Laura Matthews; Editing by Nick
Zieminski)