March 12 (Reuters) - The number of new federal lawsuits
fell 14% in the 2024 fiscal year as a result of a decline in
mass tort litigation driven in large part by 3M's ( MMM ) decision to
strike a $6 billion deal to settle litigation over its combat
earplugs, according to the federal judiciary.
The steep drop off in lawsuits contributed to an overall 11%
decline in criminal and civil filings in the fiscal year that
ended Sept. 30, according to a report released on Tuesday by the
Administrative Office of the U.S. Courts.
New criminal cases meanwhile grew 6% to 69,802, driven in
part by a 30% increase in filings for defendants charged with
immigration offenses during the final fiscal year of Democratic
President Joe Biden's administration.
Those immigration cases constituted 37% of all criminal
filings and helped offset an 8% decline in filings involving
defendants charged with drug crimes, the judiciary said.
The decline in civil cases was fueled by a 41% drop-off in
personal injury cases, which plummeted to 69,506, the judiciary
said. Excluding mass tort cases, all other types of civil
lawsuits held steady in 2024, falling less than 1%.
The trend marked a shift from a year earlier, when the
judiciary reported a 24% increase in new lawsuits driven by a
flood of cases by people alleging they were injured by products
like 3M's ( MMM ) combat earplugs and Johnson & Johnson's ( JNJ ) talcum powder.
But 2024 was a different story, as personal injury case
filings plummeted 41% to 69,506, the judiciary said.
The mass tort involving 3M ( MMM ) was the largest federal
multidistrict litigation in U.S. history, with hundreds of
thousands of lawsuits by current and former U.S. military
service members alleging they suffered hearing loss as a result
of using the company's Combat Arms Earplugs products.
3M ( MMM ) in August 2023 agreed to pay $6.01 billion to settle
nearly 260,000 lawsuits, which were consolidated before a
federal judge in Florida's Northern District. Post settlement,
that district saw a 50% reduction in new personal injury cases
as it received fewer cases concerning 3M ( MMM ), the report said.
New Jersey's federal court - where the federal J&J talc
litigation is consolidated - saw a 65% decline in such cases.
J&J is seeking through a subsidiary's proposed $10 billion
bankruptcy plan to resolve thousands of lawsuits alleging that
its baby powder caused ovarian cancer. J&J denies the
allegations and says its products are safe.
The judiciary said the Northern District of Illinois saw a
69% decline in product liability lawsuits primarily due to a
drop in multidistrict cases filed there over claims that hair
relaxer products made by L'Oreal USA, Revlon and others cause
cancer. The companies deny wrongdoing.
Read more:
Mass torts against 3M ( MMM ), J&J fueled spike in new federal
lawsuits in 2023
New federal lawsuits continued to fall in 2022 amid
pandemic, judiciary says
New federal lawsuits, appeals fell in 2021 amid pandemic -
judiciary