NEW YORK, June 14 (Reuters) - A U.S. bankruptcy judge on
Friday ordered a court-supervised liquidation of conspiracy
theorist Alex Jones' personal assets, but he dismissed the
bankruptcy of Jones' company Free Speech Systems without
ordering it to be liquidated.
U.S. Bankruptcy Judge Christopher Lopez appointed a
Chapter 7 trustee to sell Jones' assets, including his ownership
stake in Free Speech Systems, the parent company of his Infowars
website. Proceeds would go to pay Jones' creditors, relatives of
20 students and six staff members killed in the 2012 mass
shooting at Sandy Hook Elementary School in Newtown,
Connecticut.
But Lopez declined to force Infowars itself into a
separate liquidation, instead saying at a court hearing in
Houston, Texas that Jones could continue to run the company
until the trustee sells his ownership stake.
Lopez rejected an argument by some of the Sandy Hook
families that Jones should not be allowed to regain control of
his company. The judge said the bankruptcy court's supervision
had never impacted Jones' broadcasts.
"There's been lots of talk about whether Mr Jones has
regained control of the business, but the reality is he never
really lost it," Lopez said.
The split ruling will mean further litigation between
Jones, his company, and the Sandy Hook families, including
battles over $6 million in cash held by Free Speech Systems. The
families also will continue trying to collect money that Jones
kept from them by sending it to his wife and father and close
associates.
The proposed liquidation of Free Speech Systems split
the Sandy Hook families. Families who sued Jones in Connecticut
argued that an immediate shutdown would prevent him from hiding
the company's cash or working to undermine the company from the
inside. Families who sued Jones in Texas argued instead that he
would pay more in the long run if he kept control of his
business instead of "selling it for scraps."
"You can't control Alex Jones," said Avi Moshenberg, an
attorney for the Texas families. "What you can do, what the law
allows, is to make Alex Jones and Free Speech Systems pay on the
judgments that were rendered by juries."
Jones' attorney, Vickie Driver, said the Connecticut
families wanted to override Jones' First Amendment right to free
speech. Even forcing Infowars into liquidation "doesn't stop Mr.
Jones from saying what he wants, when he wants, on his
broadcast," Driver said in court.
Chris Mattei, an attorney for the Connecticut families,
said after the ruling that it was a "good day," and said that
Infowars is "soon-to-be defunct."
"Alex Jones is neither a martyr nor a victim," Mattei
said. "He is the perpetrator of the worst defamation in American
history."
Lopez appeared to fight back tears at one point in his
ruling, after pointing out the painful irony of deciding the
fate of Infowars just before Father's Day. Lopez said he "had no
words" to describe the pain of losing a child.
"I wish I would have picked a better day," Lopez said.
Lopez deferred decisions on some demands by the Sandy Hook
families, who have sought control over Jones' social media
accounts and the ability to choose the trustee who will be
responsible for collecting assets from Jones to pay some of the
$1.5 billion in defamation judgments that courts have awarded to
the families. Those decisions can be made later, Lopez said.
Jones filed bankruptcy protection 17 months ago, but he was
unable to reach a settlement that would reduce the $1.5 billion
he owes to the Sandy Hook families after courts in Connecticut
and Texas ruled that he defamed them with repeated false
statements about the massacre.
Jones claimed for years that the Sandy Hook killings were
staged with actors as part of a government plot to seize
Americans' guns. Jones has since acknowledged that the shooting
occurred.
The judge overseeing Jones' bankruptcy has ruled that most
of the debt will survive after a liquidation, because it
resulted from "willful and malicious" conduct.
(Reporting by Dietrich Knauth; Editing by David Gregorio and
Alexia Garamfalvi)