Oct 1 (Reuters) - A U.S. appeals court has temporarily
blocked the National Labor Relations Board from deciding whether
Amazon.com ( AMZN ) must bargain with a union representing workers at a
New York City warehouse, the first in the company's history.
A three-judge panel of the 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals
on Monday stayed the NLRB's administrative case against Amazon ( AMZN )
pending the appeal of what the company called a "constructive
denial" by a Texas federal judge of its bid to stop the board
case from moving forward.
Amazon ( AMZN ) sued the NLRB last month, claiming the agency's
in-house enforcement proceedings violate the U.S. Constitution.
About 20 similar lawsuits have been filed around the country by
other businesses seeking to block NLRB cases against them.
Amazon ( AMZN ) did not immediately respond to a request for comment.
An NLRB spokeswoman declined to comment.
The 2022 election at the Staten Island warehouse known as
JFK8 was the first and so far only successful union campaign in
Amazon's ( AMZN ) history. Workers at three other Amazon ( AMZN ) warehouses have
voted against unionizing.
The NLRB has issued scores of complaints accusing Amazon ( AMZN ) of
illegal union-busting tactics during those campaigns, including
firing union supporters, making threats, and holding mandatory
anti-union meetings. Amazon ( AMZN ) has denied wrongdoing.
The labor board in August upheld the results of the JFK8
election and is now considering claims that Amazon ( AMZN ) has illegally
refused to engage in bargaining.
The company last week asked the 5th Circuit to take up its
case after U.S. District Judge Xavier Rodriguez in San Antonio
delayed in ruling on the company's motion for a preliminary
injunction blocking the NLRB case.
Amazon ( AMZN ) said that because the NLRB could rule at any time,
Rodriguez had effectively denied the company an injunction by
not ruling more quickly.
Rodriguez then denied Amazon's ( AMZN ) motion on Sunday, while
granting the NLRB's motion to transfer the lawsuit out of his
Texas court. Rodriguez said the case belongs in federal court in
Washington, D.C., where the NLRB is based and will decide
Amazon's ( AMZN ) case, but stayed his decision pending an appeal by the
company.
Amazon ( AMZN ) in a letter to the 5th Circuit on Monday said
Rodriguez lacked jurisdiction to issue the ruling because the
company had already filed an appeal.
The 5th Circuit panel included Circuit Judges Jerry Smith
and Kurt Engelhardt, who are appointees of Republican
presidents.
Circuit Judge James Graves, who was appointed by Democratic
former President Barack Obama, dissented from the stay, saying
the court should wait until Amazon ( AMZN ) appeals Rodriguez's decision.
The case is Amazon.com Services v. NLRB, 5th U.S. Circuit
Court of Appeals, No. 24-50761.
For Amazon ( AMZN ): Kurt Larkin and Amber Rogers of Hunton Andrews
Kurth
For the NLRB: Tyler Wiese
Read more:
NLRB wins transfer of Amazon ( AMZN ) lawsuit from Texas to D.C.
Amazon ( AMZN ) takes challenge to NLRB's structure to US appeals
court
Amazon ( AMZN ) challenges US labor board's structure in lawsuit over
union election
Amazon ( AMZN ) gets labor board complaint on failure to bargain with
New York union
Amazon ( AMZN ) loses challenge to union's election win at NYC
warehouse
SpaceX wins block on US labor board case over severance
agreements
US judge blocks NLRB case against energy firm challenging
agency's structure
US judge rejects medical center's bid to 'neuter' NLRB
(Reporting by Daniel Wiessner in Albany, New York)