financetom
Business
financetom
/
Business
/
Analysis-Google, Apple breakups on the agenda as global regulators target tech
News World Market Environment Technology Personal Finance Politics Retail Business Economy Cryptocurrency Forex Stocks Market Commodities
Analysis-Google, Apple breakups on the agenda as global regulators target tech
Mar 24, 2024 2:22 PM

BRUSSELS/STOCKHOLM (Reuters) - Big Tech is facing its biggest challenge in decades as antitrust regulators on both sides of the Atlantic crack down on alleged anti-competitive practices that could result in break-up orders to Apple and Alphabet's Google, a first for the industry.

That in turn could inspire watchdogs around the world to pile on, as evidenced in the growing number of antitrust probes in various countries following the opening of EU and U.S. cases. Since AT&T was broken up exactly 40 years ago, no company has faced the possibility of a regulator-led break-up in the United States until now.

Google has said it disagreed with the EU's accusations while Apple said the U.S. lawsuit is wrong on the facts and the law.

In 1984, AT&T, also known as Ma Bell, was broken up into seven independent companies called "Baby Bells" to open up one of the most powerful monopolies of the 20th century. AT&T, Verizon and Lumen are currently the only surviving entities.

Regulators now allege companies such as Apple and Google have built impenetrable ecosystems around their products, making it difficult for customers to switch to rival services, which led to the coining of the term walled gardens. 

The U.S Department of Justice on Wednesday warned Apple, a $2.7 trillion company, that a break-up order is not excluded as a remedy to restore competition after it teamed up with 15 states to sue the iPhone maker for monopolising the smartphone market, thwarting rivals and inflating prices.

Even so, it will likely take years to decide the case, which Apple has vowed to fight.

The U.S. actions come on the heels of other mounting threats across Europe this week.

Big Tech will face more scrutiny shortly with Apple, Meta Platforms and Alphabet likely to be investigated for potential Digital Markets Act (DMA) violations that could lead to hefty fines and even break-up orders for repeated breaches, people with direct knowledge of the matter told Reuters on Thursday, on the condition of anonymity.

EU antitrust chief Margrethe Vestager helped pave the way for drastic measures last year when she accused Google of anti-competitive practices in its money-spinning adtech business and that it may have to divest its sell-side tools.

She said that requiring Google to sell some of its assets seemed to be the only way to avoid conflicts of interest as it would prevent Google from allegedly favouring its own online digital advertising technology services versus advertisers and online publishers.

Vestager is expected to issue a final decision by the end of the year.

European Parliament lawmaker Andreas Schwab, who was heavily involved in drafting landmark EU DMA tech rules that kicked in this month, said lawmakers want bold action against Big Tech which flouts rules.

"If they don't comply with the DMA, you can imagine what Parliament will ask for. Break-ups. The ultimate goal is to make markets open, fair and allow more innovation," he said on Friday.

BREAKING UP IS HARD TO DO

It is far from certain that regulators will issue break-up order as they mull options and any action may just result in a fine. Legal experts also suggested the case against Apple, drawing from the 1998 case against Microsoft, could be more difficult this time.  

"In the European Union, there is less of a tradition, with splitting a company seen as a last resort. It has never happened before," said a Commission official, speaking on condition of anonymity.

Apple's highly integrated system would also make a break-up difficult compared with Google, said lawyer Damien Geradin at Geradin Partners, who is advising several app developers in other cases against Apple.

"It seems to me much more complicated. You are talking about something that is integrated, for example you can't force Apple to divest its App Store. That doesn't make sense," he said.

He said it would be better to impose behavioural remedies on Apple that obligates it to do certain things while in the case of Google, a break-up order could simply target acquisitions made to strengthen its key services.

"What's more likely is they (DOJ) go for remedies like opening up hardware functionality, or making sure developers aren't being discriminated against in terms of pricing," said Max von Thun, director of advocacy group Open Markets. 

"I think they want to say that everything's on the table, but it doesn't necessarily mean they'll choose that path," he said.

Apple gets most of its nearly $400 billion-a-year revenue from selling hardware -- iPhones, Macs, iPads and Watches -- followed by its Services business, which will brings in roughly $100 billion a year.

Structural remedies such as break-ups will ultimately be tested in courts, said Assimakis Komninos, partner at law firm White & Case.

"I would say that experiences of imposed structural measures, such as breakups, are not many, but the small past experience shows that this is very tricky, aside from the formidable legal challenges," he said. 

Comments
Welcome to financetom comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
Related Articles >
Melinda Gates to step down as co-chair of Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation
Melinda Gates to step down as co-chair of Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation
May 13, 2024
May 13 (Reuters) - Melinda French Gates said on Monday she is stepping down as co-chair of the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation. Her last day of work at the foundation will be June 7. (Reporting by Yuvraj Malik in Bengaluru) ...
Penn Entertainment Poised for 'Higher for Longer' Losses, BofA Says in Downgrade
Penn Entertainment Poised for 'Higher for Longer' Losses, BofA Says in Downgrade
May 13, 2024
12:04 PM EDT, 05/13/2024 (MT Newswires) -- Penn Entertainment's ( PENN ) shares are now more of a deep value turnaround than a growth opportunity and, in the absence of a big acceleration, the company is poised for higher for longer losses that can significantly impact Q4 and 2025 projections, BofA Securities said in a note Monday. ESPN Bet's $1...
Market Chatter: Morgan Stanley Leads $1.8 Billion Staples' Leveraged Loan Sale For Refinancing
Market Chatter: Morgan Stanley Leads $1.8 Billion Staples' Leveraged Loan Sale For Refinancing
May 13, 2024
12:15 PM EDT, 05/13/2024 (MT Newswires) -- Morgan Stanley ( MS ) is leading banks on Staples' $1.8 billion leveraged loan sale and the call for the transaction is slated for Tuesday, Bloomberg reported Monday, citing a person familiar with the matter. Proceeds from the loan sale and $2.35 billion of secured debt will be used to refinance other borrowings,...
Vecima Networks Teams Up With Youcast to Deploy MediaScale Open CDN Service in Brazil
Vecima Networks Teams Up With Youcast to Deploy MediaScale Open CDN Service in Brazil
May 13, 2024
12:15 PM EDT, 05/13/2024 (MT Newswires) -- Vecima Networks ( VNWTF ) said Monday it joined forces with Youcast to launch its MediaScale Open CDN technology for telecommunications and content providers in Brazil. Vecima, recognizing the unique opportunity to make a substantial impact on content distribution in South America, presented its MediaScale Open CDN solution to Youcast and was awarded...
Copyright 2023-2026 - www.financetom.com All Rights Reserved