*
13 bln euro award dwarfed by wider multinational tax take
*
Opposition says money should be spent quickly
*
Government rules out using money in pre-election budget
(Recasts, adds comments from finance minister, opposition)
By Padraic Halpin and Conor Humphries
DUBLIN, Sept 10 (Reuters) - An EU court order that Apple ( AAPL )
pay Ireland 13 billion euros ($14.4 billion) in back taxes
triggered mixed feelings in Dublin on Tuesday as the government
assessed possible reputational damage and rebuffed opposition
calls for the cash to be spent quickly.
Ireland had fought the EU back-tax bill alongside Apple ( AAPL )
since 2016, seeking to defend its position as the location of
choice for U.S. multinationals in Europe - and the billions of
euros in direct and indirect taxes they bring in each year.
The government played down the finding by the Court of
Justice of the European Union that it granted the iPhone maker
unlawful aid through its tax treatment as an issue "of
historical relevance only" due to changes in tax rules since.
But it reluctantly accepted that it must now take the back
taxes held in an escrow fund estimated at 13.8 billion euros.
Finance Minister Jack Chambers said ministers would
"carefully consider" in the coming weeks how best to use the
money but that it would not be added to next month's budget pot.
Opposition parties, who have criticised the government's
decision in 2016 to join Apple ( AAPL ) in appealing the ruling, repeated
calls for the windfall to be used quickly to fix a housing
crisis and help fund stretched services like healthcare.
"If they (the government) had their way, the taxpayer would
be down more than 13 billion euros... The mind boggles," Mary
Lou McDonald, leader of the main opposition Sinn Fein party,
told reporters.
The government has already set out plans to cut taxes and
hike spending in an 8.3 billion euro pre-election Oct. 1 budget,
to the extent that it will break its own fiscal rule, meant to
cap spending growth at 5%.
Ireland is already taking in more tax than it can spend -
primarily due to surging corporate tax receipts paid by foreign
companies like Apple ( AAPL ) - and has set up a new sovereign wealth
fund it hopes to grow to 100 billion euros by 2035.
It expects to take in 24.5 billion euros in corporate tax
this year, mainly from big foreign multinationals, and had
collected significantly more than expected by the end of August.
Spending Minister Paschal Donohoe said increasing spending
any further now risked stoking inflation again just as it has
stabilised at around 1%.
Other EU countries might also lay claim to part of the funds
following Tuesday's final ruling in the antitrust case, although
Chambers said it was not yet possible to comment on whether they
would do so.
REPUTATIONAL DAMAGE
Foreign multinationals, attracted in large part due to low
tax rates, make up around 11% of the entire labour market in
Ireland - twice the workforce they had when the Apple ( AAPL )
controversy broke in 2013.
Peter Vale, tax partner at Grant Thornton, said Tuesday's
ruling might do temporary damage to Ireland's reputation but was
unlikely to impact foreign direct investment.
"While it does relate to a bygone era, even last week,
(ex-U.S. President Donald) Trump accused Ireland of being a tax
haven," Vale said. "We'll vigorously defend that, but it only
adds further fuel to the fire to those sort of assertions."
Since the EU order in 2016, Ireland has made a number of
changes to its corporate tax code and did the once unthinkable
by dropping opposition to giving up its prized 12.5% corporate
tax rate as part of an overhaul of global tax rules.
($1 = 0.9057 euros)
(Writing by Conor Humphries and Padraic Halpin; Editing by
Jason Neely and Catherine Evans)