Sept 19 (Reuters) - Medical device maker Axonics ( AXNX ) has
convinced a jury in California federal court that it did not
violate rival Medtronic's ( MDT ) patent rights in
nerve-stimulation technology.
The jury agreed with Axonics ( AXNX ) on Wednesday that its R15
neurostimulation system did not infringe Medtronic ( MDT ) patents
related to its own devices, which are used to treat incontinence
and overactive bladder.
A Medtronic ( MDT ) spokesperson said on Thursday that the company
disagrees with the verdict, will seek to overturn it, and will
continue with a related case against Axonics ( AXNX ) at the U.S.
International Trade Commission.
Axonics ( AXNX ) CEO Raymond Cohen said in a statement that he was
pleased with the verdict and that Medtronic's ( MDT ) lawsuit had been
meant to "stifle competition, limit patient and physician
choice, and protect the incumbent's monopoly in sacral
neuromodulation."
The companies both make medical devices that are implanted
into patients' lower backs to treat bladder and bowel control
issues by stimulating the sacral nerve. Medtronic ( MDT ) filed the
lawsuit in 2019, accusing Axonics' ( AXNX ) devices of using the same
nerve-stimulation technology as Medtronic's ( MDT ) InterStim system.
Axonics ( AXNX ) denied the allegations and argued that the three
patents at issue in the trial were invalid. The jury on
Wednesday upheld the patents' validity while finding that
Axonics' ( AXNX ) products did not infringe them.
Axonics ( AXNX ) separately sued Medtronic ( MDT ) in California federal
court in 2022, accusing the company of monopolizing the market
for the systems and making false statements about Axonics ( AXNX )
products. Medtronic ( MDT ) denied the claims, and the case is still
ongoing.
The case is Medtronic Inc v. Axonics Modulation Technologies
Inc, U.S. District Court for the Central District of California,
No. 8:19-cv-02115.
For Medtronic ( MDT ): Nimalka Wickramasekera, Brian Nisbet, George
Lombardi and Peggy Dayton of Winston & Strawn
For Axonics ( AXNX ): Matthew Powers, Aaron Nathan, Azra
Hadzimehmedovic and William Nelson of Tensegrity Law Group;
David Stein of Olson Stein
(Reporting by Blake Brittain in Washington)