* Appeals court revives whistleblower lawsuit
* AbbVie ( ABBV ), AstraZeneca ( AZN ), Novartis, Sanofi are the
defendants
* Adventist Health says Medicare and Medicaid were
overcharged
By Jonathan Stempel
March 17 (Reuters) - A U.S. appeals court on Tuesday
revived a whistleblower lawsuit accusing four large drugmakers
of defrauding the federal and state governments out of hundreds
of millions of dollars by overcharging on medications for
low-income and uninsured patients.
In a 3-0 decision, the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in
Pasadena, California said AbbVie ( ABBV ), AstraZeneca ( AZN ),
Novartis and Sanofi must defend against
claims they violated the federal False Claims Act through their
involvement in the Section 340B Drug Pricing Program.
Created by Congress in 1992, the program lets medical
providers buy drugs at discounted prices, and at no more than
$0.01 -- known as "penny pricing" -- when the drugs' statutory
ceiling prices fall below zero.
Adventist Health System/West, a Roseville, California-based
nonprofit with more than 440 hospitals and clinics, said many
years of overcharges by the four drugmakers caused Medicare and
Medicaid to pay inflated reimbursements.
It said this stopped when the U.S. Department of Health and
Human Services decided in 2019 to impose large civil fines for
Section 340B pricing violations.
Circuit Judge Roopali Desai wrote for the appeals court that
while Section 340B does not give medical providers a private
right to sue drugmakers for overcharges, they can sue under the
False Claims Act to recover damages for alleged fraud that
causes "financial loss" to the government.
Adventist's claims "belong to the government," and "it does
not matter" that Adventist cannot sue on its own behalf, Desai
wrote.
AbbVie ( ABBV ), AstraZeneca ( AZN ), Novartis, Sanofi and their respective
lawyers declined to comment. Lawyers for Adventist did not
immediately respond to similar requests.
The appeals court returned the case to U.S. District
Judge Dale Fischer in Los Angeles, who dismissed it in March
2024.
The False Claims Act lets whistleblowers sue on behalf of
the government, and share in recoveries.