TORONTO, March 19 (Reuters) - Some of Canada's biggest
banks have admitted for the first time that their
climate-related finance efforts may not necessarily curtail
emissions growth, following years of pressure from climate
activists for banks to be more transparent about their claims on
climate goals.
Canadian banks, said to be one of the biggest fossil fuel
financiers globally, have drawn criticism from climate activists
and investors for years claiming they are using
sustainability-linked financing (SLF) merely for pretence of a
lower carbon footprint rather than take meaningful steps in that
direction.
In their latest annual climate reports released over the
past week, many Canadian banks have pledged billions of dollars
in sustainable financing to decarbonize high-emitting sectors,
while highlighting major challenges to meeting their goals.
Bank of Nova Scotia ( BNS ), CIBC and TD
noted that their sustainable finance targets may not necessarily
curtail the growth of emissions.
"The question for regulators will be whether it's enough
for the banks to insert these brief disclaimers deep in their
ESG reporting or whether they need to do a better job telling
their investors and the public that these huge financial numbers
they promote as green aren't necessarily adding up to emissions
reductions at all," said Matt Price, executive director of
Investors for Paris Compliance.
In January, the group urged securities regulators to
investigate major Canadian banks on their climate-related claims
and alleged misleading disclosures.
The complaint gave climate activists more fuel in their
fight, that is part of a broader international push for
accountability on corporate climate pledges.
Price said the latest revelations were still not enough to
obviate the need for an investigation. He noted that TD, for
example, is still leaning on its C$500 billion sustainable
finance initiative, without the qualifiers it makes elsewhere,
which he says is misleading.
Canada is the world's fourth-biggest oil producer, and
energy sector contributes about 5% to the country's GDP. Despite
the influence of the oil sector on the economy, the federal
government has set out aggressive emissions goals that include
pushing companies in the sector to cut emissions up to 38% from
2019 levels by 2030.
Bank of Nova Scotia ( BNS ) gave a total of C$132 billion
since 2018 towards its target of C$350 billion in
climate-related finance by 2030, but said that climate-related
projects "may - or may not - lead to reductions in overall
emissions."
The bank's Chief Sustainability and Communications Officer
Meigan Terry said it aims "to be transparent and support a clear
understanding" about its climate-related financing target.
CIBC echoed a similar narrative, saying "sustainable
financing may involve eligible green activities... but do not
necessarily curtail the growth of their absolute emissions."
Other big banks also highlighted the difficulties in
achieving climate goals.
Royal Bank of Canada ( RY ), Canada's No. 1 bank, said the
target of limiting global temperatures to 1.5 degrees Celsius
above preindustrial levels would be a key challenge and just 2%
of its clients have plans that are aligned with that goal.
The bank's plans this year include tripling lending for
renewable energy projects to $15 billion and boosting low-carbon
energy lending to $35 billion by 2030.
TD said greenhouse gas emissions impact of its business
activities that are eligible towards the C$500 billion
sustainable and decarbonization target cannot, be "reliably
measured at this time."
In a recent report, think tank InfluenceMap said between
2020 and 2022 the big five banks steadily increased their fossil
fuel financing exposure to an average of 18.4% in 2022 from
15.5% in 2020. That compares with an average of 6.1% for leading
US banks and 8.7% for European banks across the same period.
Several global banks have committed to "net-zero financed
emissions" by 2050 but have drawn doubts from many investors,
due to concerns over the lack of a defined goal.
Regulators in the Americas and Europe have increasingly been
worried about greenwashing, whereby companies exaggerate their
environmental credentials.