Aug 27 (Reuters) - Capital One and Discover Financial
Services ( DFS ) are defending their proposed $35 billion merger in a
U.S. court, asking a Virginia judge to dismiss a consumer
lawsuit that claimed the deal will reduce competition and drive
up prices.
Capital One and Discover in a court filing
on Monday said the consumers' allegations were "too contingent
on unknown future events" to be allowed to move ahead while U.S.
antitrust and regulatory bodies were still weighing the merger.
"Their allegations of harm are entirely speculative,
incoherent, uncertain, and not imminent," the companies told the
court.
U.S. District Judge Anthony Trenga in Alexandria federal
court on Tuesday set a hearing for Oct. 16.
Capital One, Discover and attorneys for the plaintiffs did
not immediately respond to requests for comment. The Justice
Department also did not immediately respond to a request for
comment.
Two Capital One customers in Vermont and New Jersey filed
the proposed class action in July, alleging the deal will
violate U.S. antitrust law. The merger would create the biggest
U.S. credit card issuer by balance and sixth-largest U.S. bank
by assets.
U.S. antitrust law allows private civil lawsuits challenging
proposed mergers.
Discover and American Express issue credit cards and run
their own payment processing systems. Visa and Mastercard ( MA ) do not
issue cards, but instead operate the country's largest card
payment networks.
Discover and American Express put pressure on rivals to pay
out rewards to customers to stay competitive, the consumers'
lawsuit said.
In the filing, credit card issuer Capital One said its
planned acquisition of payment network operator Discover,
announced in February, would "inject greater competition" into
the market.
The proposed Capital One purchase of Discover has drawn
calls by some members of Congress for U.S. regulators to block
the deal.
The case is Baker v. Capital One Financial ( COF ), U.S. District
Court for the Eastern District of Virginia, No. 1:24-cv-01265.
For plaintiffs: Brian Dunne and Yavar Bathaee of Bathaee
Dunne
For Capital One: Ryan Shores of Cleary Gottlieb Steen &
Hamilton; John Moran of McGuireWoods; and Ryan McLeod of
Wachtell, Lipton, Rosen & Katz
For Discover: Daniel Richardson and Amanda Davidoff of
Sullivan & Cromwell
Read more:
Capital One customers sue to block $35 billion Discover
merger
Capital One, community groups square off in public meeting
on Discover deal
Capital One's $35 billion Discover deal hinges on playing
consumer champion
Capital One to buy Discover Financial in $35.3 billion
all-stock deal