March 27 (Reuters) - The Chilean government's new plan
to usher in private investment at a number of the country's
lithium salt flats may stumble over unresolved details that will
raise concerns for investors, mining executives and analysts
said on Wednesday.
Industry players said they are seeking information on how
contracts will be awarded by officials in the country that is
the world's second-biggest lithium producer and are worried
about pushback from Indigenous communities and environmental
campaigners.
Chile in April will begin seeking proposals from private
firms interested in extracting lithium, a key energy transition
material used in electric vehicle batteries, from 26 salt flats
not earmarked for state control, officials said on Tuesday.
The plan is one of the new planks of President Gabriel
Boric's 2023 lithium policy mandating public-private
partnerships.
The government will reserve two of its best salt flats,
Atacama and Maricunga, for majority control through state-run
copper miner Codelco, while progressing projects via state-run
companies at another five salt flats.
The state-developed projects alone are expected to double
Chile's output to about 500,000 metric tons of lithium carbonate
equivalent by the end of decade, Mining Minister Aurora Williams
said on Wednesday.
For the remaining 26 salt flats, officials will accept
statements of interest through July.
Nearly 100 companies from a dozen countries have already
approached the government to seek information about launching
lithium projects, Williams said, including from the U.S. and
China.
Yet, executives and analysts pointed out red flags in
Tuesday's announcement they say could put a damper on new
projects.
One concern is how the government will award lithium
contracts in salt flats where mining concessions have previously
been granted, which risks creating a kind of double ownership.
"It creates many potential conflicts, setting the stage for
future judicial problems," said Sebastian Yang, a board member
of Simco Lithium, which has a project in the Maricunga salt
flat.
"This will pose a difficulty for attracting potential
investors."
Chile's Mining Ministry did not immediately respond to a
request for comment.
Jose Hofer, a lithium adviser at consultancy SC Insights,
said other challenges that could curb investor appetite include
required state partnerships, potential pushback from Indigenous
communities and limits on extraction throughout a swath of the
salt flats due to environmental protections.
"This over layering of policies and excess of state
involvement has made Chile 'un-investable' in lithium," he said,
noting that Argentina and Brazil will likely become more
significant players compared to Chile over the next decade.
Companies must also grapple with a soft patch for lithium
prices amid a slowdown in EV sales, which has changed the
calculus for ensuring economically viable projects.
For Canada-based Wealth Minerals ( WMLLF ), moving forward
with its lithium project in the Atacama salt flat will mean
starting talks with Codelco over the terms in which the
state-owned miner will take a majority stake, said Executive
Director Marcelo Awad.
"We're optimistic and very interested in starting a
negotiation with Codelco as soon as possible," he said.