LONDON, March 8 (Reuters) - Activity on the CME's
aluminium contract has shifted up several gears in
recent months with volumes surging and the number of
participants expanding.
It's still small relative to the London Metal Exchange
(LME), which isn't going to lose its status as benchmark
price-setter any time soon. Nor will the Shanghai Futures
Exchange (ShFE) stop being the dominant futures price reference
for China's giant aluminium sector.
Rather, the significance of CME's fast-growing aluminium
contract is what it says about aluminium's shifting dynamics.
The global market is becoming less globalised and the U.S.
is starting to drift away from everyone else thanks to the
combination of import tariffs and penal duties on Russian metal
and Chinese products.
The emergence of a North American pricing point is a logical
evolution in this tectonic realignment of the market landscape.
PHYSICAL DRIFT
The CME's first aluminium contract was delisted in 2009
after the U.S. exchange failed to lure users away from the
dominant London market.
It was ironically the LME itself that opened the door again
for its U.S. rival a few years later.
Long load-out queues at LME warehouses in Detroit caused
U.S. physical premiums to surge. The LME price stayed low but
buyers were paying ever more for their metal and were unable to
hedge the pricing gap.
The CME launched a U.S. Midwest premium contract in 2013
followed a couple of years later by European and Japanese
premium contracts. Volume last year across the four contracts
totalled almost four million tonnes.
The LME's premium contracts, launched much later, notched up
volumes of just 202,000 tonnes last year.
The Midwest premium briefly converged with the rest of the
world before ballooning wider again when the Trump
Administration imposed 10% import duties in 2018.
The Biden Administration's policy of de-risking supply by
closing the door on Russian imports has cemented the structural
divergence with other regions.
U.S. physical buyers are currently paying around $387 per
metric ton over the futures price for metal. Those in Europe are
paying around $250 and Japanese buyers just $120.
That futures price has until now been set on the LME. But
maybe for not much longer.
GROWTH SPURT
The CME tried again in 2014 with a futures contract to match
its premium products but it lapsed into disuse late 2017 and
didn't trade at all until July 2019.
The trigger for the renewed interest was the CME's decision
to expand its delivery network from U.S. locations to
international ports, particularly those with physical arbitrage
opportunities with the LME warehousing network.
Registered stocks were zero prior to June 2019. Today they
stand at 45,905 tons, most of it in heavily-used LME locations
such as Malaysia's Port Klang and Gwangyang in South Korea.
With inventory has come trading volume. Activity in the
aluminium contract nearly tripled last year to 30.6 million
tons. That's dwarfed by the 1.4 billion tons transacted on the
LME, although the difference is accentuated by the LME's unique
trading system.
A more useful comparison is with the ShFE, which like the
CME, offers a vanilla cash-settled futures contract.
CME volumes in the first two months of this year came to 9.3
million tonnes, compared with 44.0 million in Shanghai. And the
U.S. product is still growing fast.
So too are the number of users, over 600 last year compared
with 357 in 2022, according to the exchange.
CME has also launched aluminium options, which just recorded
their best volume month in February.
CME ALL-IN ALUMINIUM
Although the CME's rising aluminium fortunes have until now
been linked via arbitrage with those of its competitor across
the Atlantic, there are signs that the contract's success is
generating domestic traction.
A key development came in April last year, when price
reporting agency Platts, part of S&P Global Commodity Insights,
began publishing a CME-basis all-in price.
Whereas physical buyers would previously hedge their basis
risk on the LME and their premium risk on the CME, the new
pricing tool allows both components to be executed on the CME.
Domestic players such as PerenniAL Aluminum are now offering
buyers a CME all-in price reference in this year's term supply
contracts, according to CEO Brian Hesse, quoted in a CME update
on the contract.
Industrial users are being joined by investors.
United States Commodity Fund (USCF) announced the launch of
the USCF Aluminum Strategy Fund in October. It will trade basis
the CME contract, hoping to attract investors looking for
exposure to aluminium as a critical energy transition metal.
Although included in all the major commodity indices,
aluminium has to date failed to attract much retail speculative
interest. CME, which offers investor friendly micro products in
both precious metals and copper, would seem a good fit for
smaller players unable to access the wholesale market in London.
CME is assembling the building blocks to become an aluminium
price-setter for the North American market.
REGIONAL SPLITS
This is not necessarily bad news for either London or
Shanghai. Three regional futures exchanges can be mutually
beneficial thanks to increased arbitrage possibilities.
Copper, which has traded on U.S. exchanges since the
nineteenth century, is a good example of profitable
co-existence.
But for aluminium, shifting from London dominance to
regional price formation is a completely new development.
It is, though, no more than a reflection of geopolitical
reality as what was a highly globalised supply chain drifts
apart into trading blocs.
The opinions expressed here are those of the author, a
columnist for Reuters
(Editing by David Evans)