Nov 26 (Reuters) - The U.S. Treasury Department acted
outside its authority when it sanctioned cryptocurrency mixer
Tornado Cash in 2022 and accused it of helping launder over $7
billion for North Korean hackers and other malicious cyber
actors, a U.S. appeals court ruled.
A three-judge panel of the New Orleans-based 5th U.S.
Circuit Court of Appeals on Tuesday sided with six users of
Tornado Cash who with the financial backing of the
cryptocurrency exchange Coinbase filed a lawsuit
challenging the sanctions.
Cryptocurrency mixers are anonymized software tools that
allow users to conceal the source or owner of digital assets.
The sanctions had been imposed by the Treasury Department's
Office of Foreign Assets Control pursuant to the International
Emergency Economic Powers Act.
OFAC blacklisted Tornado Cash after concluding it was
helping launder proceeds of cyber crimes, including more than
$455 million stolen by the Lazarus Group, a North Korean
government-backed hacking group.
Writing for a panel comprised of conservative judges, U.S.
Circuit Judge Don Willett said federal law only gave OFAC the
authority to regulate property, which Tornado Cash's immutable
crypto-mixing smart contracts did not constitute.
Such self-executing smart contracts, or "mixers," provided
increased anonymity by collecting, pooling and shuffling
cryptocurrencies that were deposited by many users and could not
be altered, removed or controlled, Willett said.
The judge, who was appointed by Republican President-elect
Donald Trump during his first four-year term, said the design of
that privacy-enabling software code rendered it incapable of
being owned or deemed legally as property.
He acknowledged "the real-world downsides of certain
uncontrollable technology falling outside of OFAC's sanctioning
authority." But Willett said it was up to Congress to update the
1977 law for the internet age, not the court.
The Treasury Department did not respond to requests for
comment.
Paul Grewal, the chief legal officer of Coinbase, in a post
on X hailed the ruling as "a historic win for crypto and all who
cares about defending liberty." Coinbase had argued that OFAC's
decision to sanction an entire technology could stifle
innovation and undermine privacy.
In May, one of Tornado Cash's developers, Alexey Pertsev,
was sentenced to five years and four months in prison in the
Netherlands for money laundering. Two Tornado Cash founders,
Roman Semenov and Roman Storm, were separately charged last year
with money laundering and sanctions violations by federal
prosecutors in New York.