*
Companies say law is unconstitutional
*
Lawsuits seek to block enforcement
*
PBMs have faced scrutiny in multiple states
(Updates to include CVS lawsuit in paragraph 1, additional
information)
By Diana Novak Jones
CHICAGO, May 29 (Reuters) - CVS and Express
Scripts filed lawsuits on Thursday seeking to overturn an
Arkansas state law set to go into effect next year that would
ban pharmacy benefit managers from owning pharmacies.
The law puts an unconstitutional restriction on interstate
commerce by burdening out-of-state companies like Express
Scripts, which is based in St. Louis, and CVS, which is based in
Rhode Island, the companies said in separate lawsuits filed in
Little Rock federal court.
Express and CVS, which are among the nation's largest
pharmacy benefit managers, both seek a declaration that the law
is unconstitutional and an order barring its enforcement.
Sam Dubke, a spokesperson for Arkansas Governor Sarah
Huckabee Sanders, a Republican, who signed the law in April,
said in a statement, "these big drug middlemen are only
attacking Arkansas in the courts because they're worried other
states will join Governor Sanders in fighting for patient access
and affordable prescriptions."
The lawsuits name the executive director and members of the
Arkansas State Board of Pharmacy, which regulates the state's
pharmacies, as defendants.
In a statement, Express Scripts, which is a unit of Cigna
Group ( CI ), said the law will likely bar it from mailing
prescriptions to thousands of Arkansas residents through its
mail-order pharmacy business.
"While Arkansas politicians claim this law was designed to
lower drug prices and increase access to medications, it will do
just the opposite," said Andrea Nelson, Cigna's ( CI ) chief legal
officer.
CVS, which operates 23 pharmacies in Arkansas, said it is
exploring all possible options to keep them open, including the
lawsuit.
Pharmacy benefit managers serve as intermediaries,
negotiating prescription drug prices with drugmakers on behalf
of employers and health plans. They also often manage pharmacy
networks and operate mail-order pharmacies.
Arkansas' law, which is set to go into effect in January,
bars PBMs from receiving permits to dispense prescription
medication and revokes PBMs' existing permits, according to the
legislation.
The law is meant to cut down on anticompetitive behavior by
the PBMs, which set the prices for the drugs they dispense
through their pharmacies, according to the governor's office.
PBMs' business practices have drawn increasing scrutiny in
recent years from U.S. lawmakers looking to lower drug prices,
state attorneys general and from the Federal Trade Commission,
which accused the three largest PBMs of driving up the cost of
insulin drugs.
Michigan Attorney General Dana Nessel, a Democrat, sued
Express Scripts and another PBM, Prime Therapeutics, last month
over claims they conspired to reduce reimbursement rates for
independent pharmacies. That litigation is ongoing, court
records show.
Representatives for the PBMs did not immediately respond to
requests for comment about the Michigan allegations.
(Additional reporting by Amina Niasse in New York; Editing by
Leigh Jones, Bill Berkrot and Sonali Paul)