*
Bill aims to stop firms leaving Delaware for other states
*
Critics label it a "billionaire's bill" benefiting
controlling
shareholders
*
Opposition includes shareholder attorneys, pension fund
managers
(Updates with result of vote)
By Tom Hals
DOVER, Delaware, March 25 (Reuters) -
Delaware lawmakers approved on Tuesday an overhaul of the
state's corporate law in a bid to keep powerful business leaders
like Mark Zuckerberg from moving their companies' legal home to
another state, although opponents call it a giveaway to
billionaires.
The law, known as SB 21, was approved by a vote by
Delaware's House and now goes to Governor Matt Meyer, who has
said he will sign it.
The bill mostly impacts companies with a controlling
shareholder, like Meta Platforms ( META ), which is controlled
by Zuckerberg. The proposal provides steps that allow for a
company and its controlling shareholder to arrange deals, such
as selling corporate assets to the controller, that cannot be
challenged in court by the company's other investors.
Supporters and opponents of the bill both agreed during
Tuesday's debate that the state must prevent "DExit" -- or a
stampede of companies moving their legal home out of one of the
country's smallest and least populated states -- although they
disagreed on the strategy. While other states are trying to
attract corporations, Delaware remains home to most large public
companies in part because its corporate law protects board
directors from being sued if they are independent and act in the
company's best interest.
The state's corporate legal system, which locals refer to as
"the franchise," generates more than 20% of Delaware's budget
revenue.
"We have a million Delawareans who rely on the $2.2 billion
that the corporation franchise brings in to the state,"
Representative Krista Griffith, a Democrat, told lawmakers on
Tuesday. "What seems permanent can easily vanish."
Several companies, mostly with controlling shareholders, have
said they might or will leave Delaware, including Dropbox ( DBX )
, Meta, Tripadvisor ( TRIP ) and President Donald
Trump's media company. On Friday, Simon Property Group ( SPG ),
which is not a controlled company, asked its shareholders to
approve moving the real estate investment trust's legal home to
Indiana, where it has its headquarters, from Delaware. REITs
like Simon tend to be chartered outside of Delaware.
The proposed legislation has been labeled "the billionaire's
bill" by critics, which include attorneys for shareholders and
managers of pension funds. High-profile opposition ads included
a billboard truck featuring an image of Elon Musk waving a
chainsaw that circled Legislative Hall in Dover before lawmakers
voted.
Witnesses who testified for opponents said the bill might
prompt shareholders to encourage companies to leave Delaware for
states with corporate law that better protected their
investments. "I've got to tell you, investors' reactions to SB
21 have been surprisingly negative," Robert Jackson, a law
professor and former commissioner on the Securities and Exchange
Commission, told lawmakers.
The bill prevents shareholders from challenging deals that
are approved by a board committee that has a majority of
independent directors or by a vote by public shareholders. The
bill also limits records available to shareholders who want to
investigate a deal for conflicts.
Numerous amendments were rejected, including one that would
have eliminated the law's retroactive effective date. The law
will be effective back to February 17, which one lawmaker said
would eliminate potential legal liability for unspecified claims
that he said shareholders were investigating against the board
of Meta Platforms ( META ).
Corporate leaders have expressed frustration in recent years
over court rulings that upset certain expectations about the
state's law. Musk fueled the debate last year by urging
companies to follow Tesla and leave the state after a
Delaware judge rescinded his $56 billion pay package as CEO of
the electric car maker.