May 12 (Reuters) - A union health benefits fund has sued
top U.S. dialysis service providers DaVita ( DVA ) and Fresenius
Medical Care in federal court in Colorado for
allegedly conspiring to artificially inflate treatment costs by
billions of dollars.
The proposed nationwide class action was filed on Friday by
Pennsylvania-based United Food and Commercial Workers Local
1776, which provides benefits for thousands of members across
the United States.
DaVita ( DVA ) and Fresenius, the two largest dialysis providers in
the United States, illegally carved up areas in the country to
avoid competition, the lawsuit said.
The plaintiffs also said the companies since at least 2021
have engaged in parallel price increases that are higher than
competitors and "not adequately explained by market forces."
DaVita ( DVA ) in a statement on Monday said "the allegations in
this case are baseless, and we will defend against it
vigorously."
Fresenius declined to comment. Attorneys for United Food and
Commercial Workers Local 1776 did not immediately respond to
requests for comment.
German healthcare group Fresenius spun off Fresenius Medical
Care in 2023 and is not a defendant.
In the United States, DaVita ( DVA ) and Fresenius earn more than
90% of industry revenue for dialysis services, according to the
lawsuit. The complaint said the two companies acquired their
dominance through a "decades-long strategy of acquiring small,
independent clinics in uncontested mergers."
The lawsuit also alleged the two companies have had
opportunities to collude on pricing through their partnerships
and deals.
United Food and Commercial Workers Local 1776 pays for
dialysis services for its members. The lawsuit seeks class
status for all purchasers of outpatient dialysis services from
DaVita ( DVA ), Fresenius or one of their affiliates.
DaVita ( DVA ) is among a group of outpatient medical center
operators facing antitrust claims in the federal court in
Chicago, Illinois, over employee compensation and mobility.
The plaintiffs in that proposed class action, filed in 2021,
have alleged a conspiracy over hiring and recruitment practices
for senior employees at ambulatory surgery centers and
outpatient medical facilities suppressed pay.
An expert for the plaintiffs has estimated class-wide
damages of nearly $870 million in that case. DaVita ( DVA ) and the
other defendants in that lawsuit have denied any wrongdoing.
The case is United Food and Commercial Workers Local 1776
and Participating Employers Health and Welfare Fund v. DaVita
Inc ( DVA ) et al, U.S. District Court, District of Colorado, No.
1:25-cv-01478.
For plaintiffs: Stephen Tillery and Andrew Ellis of Korein
Tillery, Vincent Briganti of Lowey Dannenberg and Eric Young of
Young Law Group
For defendants: No appearance yet
Read more:
US drops antitrust case over healthcare hiring agreements
DaVita ( DVA ) loses bid to dismiss class 'no-poach' claims
DaVita ( DVA ) and its former CEO acquitted of U.S. antitrust
charges