*
Judge finds no proof of intent to defraud
*
Coupang ( CPNG ) alleged to rig search results, coerce suppliers
*
Shareholders, Coupang ( CPNG ) not available to comment
(Rewrites first paragraph; adds details from decision,
accusations, attempts to obtain comment, byline)
By Jonathan Stempel
NEW YORK, Sept 10 (Reuters) -
Coupang ( CPNG ), the e-commerce company often called the
Amazon of
South Korea
, won the dismissal on Wednesday of a lawsuit claiming it
defrauded shareholders during and after its 2021 initial public
offering, Wall Street's largest by a foreign company in 6-1/2
years.
U.S. District Judge Vernon Broderick in Manhattan said
shareholders led by several New York City public pension funds
failed to show Coupang ( CPNG ) and its executives intended to defraud
them, made materially misleading statements and omissions, and
ignored "red flags" that their public statements were false.
Shareholders accused Coupang ( CPNG ) of concealing unsafe working
conditions at its warehouses, manipulating search results and
having employees write product reviews to favor its
private-label brands, and coercing suppliers to boost prices on
rival platforms for products it automatically price-matched.
They said Coupang's ( CPNG ) share price fell by more than half
within a year of the March 2021 IPO as the truth came out,
including multiple investigations by South Korea's Fair Trade
Commission and a fire at a large fulfillment center.
In an 83-page decision, Broderick said many Coupang ( CPNG )
statements regarding working conditions were too broad or
"aspirational" to be misleading, while statements about its
relationships with suppliers were inspecific, true to begin with
or "puffery."
Broderick also said shareholders failed to plead "with
particularity" the circumstances of Coupang's ( CPNG ) alleged price
manipulation. He added that the company disclosed that its
employees were writing reviews.
The judge also dismissed all claims against the IPO's
underwriters including Goldman Sachs ( GS ), JPMorgan Chase ( JPM )
and Allen & Co. Broderick dismissed the lawsuit with
prejudice, meaning it cannot be brought again.
Lawyers for the shareholders, as well as New York City
Comptroller Brad Lander, who oversees the pension funds, did not
immediately respond to requests for comment. Neither Coupang ( CPNG ) nor
its lawyers immediately responded to similar requests.
Coupang ( CPNG ) was founded in 2010 by South Korean billionaire
Bom Kim, and is now headquartered in Seattle.
With backing from Softbank Group, Coupang ( CPNG )
raised $4.6 billion
in its IPO, the largest by a foreign company on Wall Street
since Chinese e-commerce company Alibaba ( BABA ) went public
in September 2014.
The case is Teachers' Retirement System of the City of
New York et al v Coupang Inc ( CPNG ) et al, U.S. District Court,
Southern District of New York, No. 22-7309.