*
Investment firm tops rival offers by CVR Energy ( CVI ), Gold
Reserve ( GDRZF )
*
Bid combining cash, credit is subject to court case
resolutions
*
Elliott's interest in Citgo follows good results from
stakes in
Marathon Petroleum ( MPC ), Phillips 66
(Adds quote from Amber CEO in paragraph 5)
By Marianna Parraga and Gary McWilliams
HOUSTON, Sept 27 (Reuters) - An affiliate of Elliott
Investment Management on Friday was named the presumptive winner
in a U.S. court auction of shares in a parent of oil refiner
Citgo Petroleum with a bid that puts an up to $7.286 billion
enterprise value on Venezuela-owned Citgo, according to a court
filing.
A U.S. district court in Delaware is auctioning shares in
Citgo parent PDV Holding to repay up to $21.3 billion in claims
against Venezuela and state-oil firm PDVSA for expropriations
and debt defaults. A second and final bidding round closed
earlier this year, leading to negotiations on terms.
The offer includes a combination of cash and credit, people
familiar with the matter said. It is subject to the resolution
of claims by holders of defaulted Venezuela bonds pursuing the
same assets, the court said.
U.S. court officer Robert Pincus said he chose Elliott unit
Amber Energy as the successful bidder, but added that "the buyer
may elect to terminate the proposed purchase agreement" if a
proposed motion to block bondholder's parallel lawsuits fails.
"We will prioritize operational excellence to lay a
foundation for stability, strength, and long-term success," said
Amber Energy CEO Gregory Goff, who joined Exxon Mobil's ( XOM )
board three years ago after retiring as Marathon Petroleum's ( MPC )
vice chairman in 2019.
Elliott declined to comment.
The investment firm's pursuit of the seventh-largest U.S.
oil refiner follows billions of dollars in gains from its stakes
in refiners Marathon Petroleum ( MPC ) and Phillips 66.
Citgo last year earned $2 billion, its second-best annual
performance. In the first six months of this year, it posted a
profit of $385 million and ended the period with a liquidity of
$3.8 billion.
Elliott submitted offers in the two bidding rounds,
competing with rival bids from U.S. oil refiner CVR Energy ( CVI )
and miner Gold Reserve ( GDRZF ). Gold Reserve ( GDRZF ) last week
quit the bidding, citing delays and uncertainty in the process.
The $7.286 billion valuation of Citgo is almost identical to
the highest offer received in the first bidding round, which
Citgo's lawyers called disappointing. The refining company was
valued at between $11 billion and $13 billion as part of the
court process.
The offer will cover only a portion of the 26 claims
approved by the court, excluding any provisions for bondholders.
Among those that could cash proceeds if the Elliott
affiliate's offer is confirmed are Crystallex, Tidewater
, ConocoPhillips ( COP ), O-I Glass ( OI ), Huntington
Ingalls, ACL Investments, Red Tree Investments and
Rusoro Mining ( RMLFF ).
TERMS CHALLENGED
The conditional nature of Elliott's bid is stirring
opposition from Venezuelan parties in the case because the judge
initially said the offer selected would have to be binding and
final.
"This action does not represent the end of the road or the
definitive closure of the process," said Citgo's supervisory
board in a release. "Even though we are facing a complex
scenario, we must clearly say PDVSA still holds ownership over
its U.S. subsidiaries and has legal means to protect its
interests."
Even though the court established a priority ranking, some
bondholders including a group led by Gramercy Distressed
Opportunity Fund have been pursuing their claims in separate
court actions, threatening to derail the sales process that has
been delayed five times.
Earlier on Friday, Pincus notified the judge he had ended
talks with holders of PDVSA's 2020 bonds without a resolution.
The bonds are collateralized with Citgo equity, so the dispute
can affect the proceeds available to creditors in the case.
Pincus did not reply to a request for comment. Thomas
Laryea, an attorney representing the Venezuela Creditor
Committee that includes holders of the 2020 bonds, declined to
comment.
Venezuela's oil minister Delcy Rodriguez this week said the
auction represents a "blatant theft" of Venezuela's assets, and
recommended Russia and other nations not to hold assets in the
United States or Europe.
Judge Stark plans to discuss next week a proposal to block
the bondholders from resorting to other courts and trying to
"jump the line" set by Delaware's creditors list. The court has
scheduled a Nov. 19 hearing to approve a sale.
Even if Stark approves the motion, the Gramercy-led group
can challenge his decision in other courts.
The bondholders have good chances of escalating their cases,
said Jose Ignacio Hernandez, a lawyer from consultancy Aurora
Macro Strategies who has closely followed the court case.
"Resolving those disputes will add at least three more
months to the sales process, making unlikely to have a closure
by mid-November as proposed," he said.