financetom
Business
financetom
/
Business
/
Elon Musk's X escapes most of lawsuit over copyrighted songs
News World Market Environment Technology Personal Finance Politics Retail Business Economy Cryptocurrency Forex Stocks Market Commodities
Elon Musk's X escapes most of lawsuit over copyrighted songs
Mar 5, 2024 4:03 PM

March 5 (Reuters) - X, the social media platform owned

by Elon Musk, on Tuesday won the dismissal of most of a lawsuit

by 17 music publishers that accused it of infringing copyrights

on nearly 1,700 songs by letting people post music online

without permission.

U.S. District Judge Aleta Trauger in Nashville, Tennessee

said the publishers could not pursue a theory of "comprehensive

general liability for infringement" against X, which Musk bought

for $44 billion in Oct. 2022.

She dismissed two infringement claims, and dismissed a third

claim for "contributory" infringement except for accusations

that X did not properly police "verified" users and serial

infringers, and failed to act on takedown notices fast enough.

Lawyers for the publishers did not immediately respond to

requests for comment. Alex Spiro, a lawyer for X, declined to

comment.

Sony Music, Universal Music and other

members of the National Music Publishers' Association trade

group had sued X last June, seeking more than $250 million of

damages.

They accused X of routinely ignoring and encouraging

copyright infringement, giving it a leg up on platforms such as

Meta Platforms' ( META ) Facebook, Google's YouTube

and ByteDance's TikTok that properly license music.

The publishers also said the problem had gotten worse since

Musk bought Twitter.

But in a 21-page decision, Trauger said X was not liable for

direct infringement, reflecting the distinction in federal

copyright law between active participants in infringement, and

parties such as X that merely provide a platform for it.

She also said X was not liable for "vicarious" infringement,

saying it was not responsible to police how posts were drafted

or obtain copyright permission in advance.

"X Corp undoubtedly had some power over X/Twitter's users

-the way that a company that provides a valued service always

has power over the customers who rely on it - but that does not

turn customers into even loose equivalents of agents or

subordinates," Trauger wrote.

Music publishers represent copyrights for songwriters, not

for songs themselves.

The case is Concord Music Group Inc et al v X Corp, U.S.

District Court, Middle District of Tennessee, No. 23-00606.

Comments
Welcome to financetom comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
Related Articles >
Chinese solar firms, ever-nimble, go further afield where US tariffs don't reach
Chinese solar firms, ever-nimble, go further afield where US tariffs don't reach
Nov 4, 2024
(Reuters) - Some of the biggest Chinese-owned solar factories in Vietnam are cutting production and laying off workers, spurred on by the expansion of U.S. trade tariffs targeting it and three other Southeast Asian countries. Meanwhile, in nearby Indonesia and Laos, a slew of new Chinese-owned solar plants are popping up, out of the reach of Washington's trade protections. Their...
Australian police search Sydney PwC office over tax leak probe
Australian police search Sydney PwC office over tax leak probe
Nov 4, 2024
SYDNEY (Reuters) - Australian police on Monday searched the PwC Australia office in Sydney as part of a probe into a former partner who leaked confidential government tax plans to the firm and its clients. A parliamentary inquiry earlier this year concluded the firm had shared the data internally and covered up its use. This step is part of the...
US tech firms warn Vietnam's planned law to hamper data centres, social media
US tech firms warn Vietnam's planned law to hamper data centres, social media
Nov 4, 2024
HANOI - U.S. tech companies have warned Vietnam's government that a draft law to tighten rules on data protection and limit data transfers abroad would hamper social media platforms and data centre operators from growing their businesses in the country. The Southeast Asian nation with a population of 100 million is one of the world's largest markets for Facebook and...
INSIGHT-Chinese solar firms, ever-nimble, go further afield where US tariffs don't reach
INSIGHT-Chinese solar firms, ever-nimble, go further afield where US tariffs don't reach
Nov 4, 2024
* Chinese solar firms build new plants in Indonesia and Laos * U.S. has expanded tariffs on other Southeast Asian nations * In Vietnam, Chinese solar companies cut output, lay off workers * For a related graphics story on the history of US solar tariffs please click here (Adds link to graphics story in bullet point) By Lewis Jackson, Phuong...
Copyright 2023-2026 - www.financetom.com All Rights Reserved