April 30 (Reuters) - A federal judge on Tuesday severely
restricted what services a former DraftKings executive could
provide sports betting rival Fanatics after finding he likely
misappropriated valuable trade secrets before taking a new job.
U.S. District Judge Julia Kobick in Boston stopped short of
barring Michael Hermalyn from working for Fanatics, as
DraftKings wanted after he quit his job to help build out its
rival's nascent team catering to "VIP" clients.
But Kobick enjoined him for a 12-month time period starting
when he began his new job on Feb. 1 from providing services
relating to any aspects of DraftKings' ( DKNG ) business that he was
involved in or for which he had received confidential
information.
Kobick said the preliminary injunction was warranted as the
evidence showed that Hermalyn had likely violated a non-compete
agreement he signed while working at DraftKings and had
misappropriated its confidential information before leaving to
become the president of Fanatics' VIP program.
A spokesperson for Fanatics, which is not a defendant, in a
statement said it was a "bit dismayed at the breadth of the
court's ruling" but appreciated that Kobick rejected DraftKings' ( DKNG )
bid to prevent Hermalyn from working for it.
"Mike is looking forward to rolling up his sleeves and
building Fanatics' business consistent with the court order,"
the Fanatics spokesperson said.
A DraftKings spokesperson called the ruling a "victory"
and said it "looks forward to continuing to prosecute its claims
against Mr. Hermalyn to ensure he is held fully accountable for
violating his legal obligations."
The ruling came in a lawsuit filed in February by
sports-betting giant DraftKings after Hermalyn, its senior vice
president of growth, resigned on Feb. 1 ahead of the Super Bowl
to join Fanatics.
Fanatics, best known for selling sports jerseys and
merchandise, launched its sportsbook last year. DraftKings has
sought to block Hermalyn, who oversaw its relationships with its
largest customers, from working there.
Kobick on Feb. 8 issued a temporary restraining order that
allowed Hermalyn to remain at Fanatics but barred him from using
DraftKings' ( DKNG ) trade secrets or soliciting its clients or
employees.
Tuesday's preliminary injunction went further by severely
restricting what tasks Hermalyn may provide Fanatics while
employed in a position very similar to the one he held at
DraftKings.
Kobick said evidence showed that Hermalyn in the days before
resigning from DraftKings used unauthorized means to transfer
DraftKings documents to himself and accessed some while staying
at the Los Angeles home of Fanatics CEO Michael Rubin.
Those records included a pitch deck presentation containing
DraftKings' ( DKNG ) strategies for building relationships with potential
business partners and a spreadsheet detailing its plans for
entertaining specific clients during the 2024 Super Bowl.
Hermalyn during an April 16 hearing denied taking or
misusing any of DraftKings' ( DKNG ) trade secrets.
But Kobick declined to credit those denials, saying that
"the evidence submitted at this stage in the proceedings
suggests that Hermalyn has struggled with candor to the Court."
She said his account suffered from "memory lapses" and
"inconsistencies" and that he had not testified credibly about
whether he tried to poach two other DraftKings employees.
Those employees, Andrew Larracey and Hayden Metz, testified
at the April 16 hearing about multi-million dollar offers they
received from Hermalyn, who spoke with them while staying at
Rubin's home after deciding to quit DraftKings.
The case is DraftKings Inc ( DKNG ) v. Hermalyn, U.S. District Court
for the District of Massachusetts, No. 1:24-cv-10299.
For DraftKings: Orin Snyder, Jason Schwartz, Harris Mufson,
Justin DiGennaro, Justine Goeke and Christine Demana of Gibson
Dunn & Crutcher and William Lee and Drew Dulberg of Wilmer
Cutler Pickering Hale & Dorr
For Hermalyn: Russell Beck and Stephen Riden of Beck Reed
Riden
Read more:
Ex-DraftKings exec denies accessing trade secrets before
Fanatics job jump
DraftKings trade-secret case is 'character assassination,'
Fanatics exec says
Ex-DraftKings exec can work at Fanatics, can't solicit
clients during Super Bowl: judge
DraftKings sues former executive for taking secrets to
sports-betting rival
(Reporting by Nate Raymond in Boston)