*
Exxon sues California citing First Amendment rights
*
California laws require emissions and climate risk
disclosures
from large companies
*
Exxon claims California's laws mislead and counteract
voluntary
reporting
By Chandni Shah
Oct 25 (Reuters) - Exxon Mobil ( XOM ) sued California
on Friday, challenging two state laws that require large
companies to publicly disclose their greenhouse gas emissions
and climate-related financial risks.
In a complaint filed in the U.S. District Court for the
Eastern District of California, Exxon argued that Senate Bills
253 and 261 violate its First Amendment rights by compelling
Exxon to "serve as a mouthpiece for ideas with which it
disagrees," and asked the court to block the state of California
from enforcing the laws.
Exxon said the laws force it to adopt California's preferred
frameworks for climate reporting, which it views as misleading
and counterproductive. The oil giant said it already reports
emissions and climate risks voluntarily, and objects to
California's frameworks.
Democrat-ruled California has long had some of the strictest
environmental rules in areas like vehicle fuel efficiency
standards and planning policy, after passing a climate change
law in 2006.
California passed two laws in 2023 that would require
companies to publicly report their greenhouse gas emissions and
climate-related financial risks.
The California laws were supported by several big companies
including Apple, Ikea and Microsoft, but opposed by several
major groups such as the American Farm Bureau Federation and
Chamber of Commerce, which called them "onerous."
SB 253 requires public and private companies that are
active in the state and generate revenue of more than $1 billion
annually to publish an extensive account of their carbon
emissions starting in 2026. The law requires the disclosure of
both the companies' own emissions and indirect emissions by
their suppliers and customers.
SB 261 requires companies that operate in the state with
over $500 million in revenue to disclose climate-related
financial risks and strategies to mitigate risk. Exxon also
argued that SB 261 conflicts with existing federal securities
laws, which already regulate what publicly traded companies must
disclose regarding financial and environmental risks.
The California Department of Justice and the California Air
Resources Board did not immediately respond to a request for
comment.