financetom
Business
financetom
/
Business
/
FDA's graphic warning labels for cigarettes are constitutional, US appeals court rules
News World Market Environment Technology Personal Finance Politics Retail Business Economy Cryptocurrency Forex Stocks Market Commodities
FDA's graphic warning labels for cigarettes are constitutional, US appeals court rules
Mar 21, 2024 3:56 PM

March 21 (Reuters) - A federal appeals court on Thursday

said a U.S. government requirement that cigarette packs and

advertisements contain graphic warnings about the dangers of

smoking is constitutional, in a victory for the Biden

administration and a defeat for the tobacco industry.

Reversing a lower court ruling, the 5th U.S. Circuit Court

of Appeals in New Orleans found that the 11 warnings required

under a 2020 Food and Drug Administration rule were "factual and

uncontroversial," and satisfied the First Amendment.

RJ Reynolds, ITG Brands, Liggett and other tobacco companies

complained that the warnings violated their free speech rights

by compelling them to endorse images that they said

misrepresented or exaggerated the harms from smoking.

Lawyers for the tobacco companies did not immediately

respond to requests for comment.

The FDA and the Department of Health and Human Services,

which both appealed the lower court ruling, did not immediately

respond to similar requests.

Though smoking has declined significantly over the decades,

nearly one in eight American adults still smoke, and cigarette

smoking kills more than 480,000 Americans a year, government

data show.

The FDA rule adopted in March 2020 during the Trump

administration required that warnings about the risks of smoking

occupy the top 50% of cigarette packs and top 20% of ads.

These warnings included depictions of feet with amputated

toes, a baby whose fetal growth had been stunted, and a woman

with a large protrusion in her neck caused by cancer, along with

written descriptions of various health risks.

The FDA said the warnings were justified by the government

interest in promoting greater understanding of the health risks

from smoking, and reducing confusion and deception.

Tobacco companies countered that the warnings went far

beyond text warnings that had been allowed since 1984, including

that smoking causes lung cancer and quitting reduces health

risks.

But in a 3-0 decision, Circuit Judge Jerry Smith said the

graphic warnings conveyed facts about the benefits of reduced

smoking, and were not unconstitutional because they "may induce

emotions" or relate to ideological or political concerns.

He also said the warnings were not unduly burdensome, saying

tobacco companies still had plenty of space on cigarette packs

and ads to convey their own messages.

In supporting the rule, the Biden administration said

graphic warnings were necessary because text-only warnings

failed to deter teenagers from smoking.

The appeals court returned the case to U.S. District Judge

J. Campbell Barker in Tyler, Texas, to assess whether the FDA

rule violated federal administrative law.

Barker did not address that argument when striking the rule

down in December 2020.

Comments
Welcome to financetom comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
Related Articles >
Erdene Sinks to 2024 Net Loss, Provides Update on Bayan Khundii Project in Mongolia
Erdene Sinks to 2024 Net Loss, Provides Update on Bayan Khundii Project in Mongolia
Mar 25, 2025
08:18 AM EDT, 03/25/2025 (MT Newswires) -- Erdene Resource Development ( ERDCF ) said Tuesday that it sank to a net loss in 2024. The company posted a net loss of $8.2 million, swinging from a 2023 net income of $522,043. The loss comes as Erdene's exploration and evaluation expenses increased to $1.9 million from $847,010 while corporate and administrative...
Market Chatter: Boeing Global President Meets China's Commerce Minister
Market Chatter: Boeing Global President Meets China's Commerce Minister
Mar 25, 2025
08:34 AM EDT, 03/25/2025 (MT Newswires) -- Boeing ( BA ) global president Brendan Nelson met with China's Commerce Minister Wang Wentao to discuss closer cooperation between the company and the country's aviation industry, Reuters reported Tuesday, citing a statement from the ministry. Wang told Nelson that China expected the company to contribute to the stability of the global aviation...
Telesat, ADN Telecom Partner to Deliver Low Earth Orbit Connectivity in South Asia
Telesat, ADN Telecom Partner to Deliver Low Earth Orbit Connectivity in South Asia
Mar 25, 2025
08:30 AM EDT, 03/25/2025 (MT Newswires) -- Telesat ( TSAT ) and ADN Telecom said Tuesday that they signed a multi-year partnership to deliver Telesat Lightspeed low earth orbit connectivity solutions across Bangladesh and South Asia. The companies said ADN Telecom will use Telesat Lightspeed services and Smart Virtual Network Operator capabilities to offer customized connectivity solutions to enterprise, maritime,...
UK's Warehouse REIT evaluates Blackstone's $633 million takeover proposal
UK's Warehouse REIT evaluates Blackstone's $633 million takeover proposal
Mar 25, 2025
March 25 (Reuters) - UK's Warehouse REIT said on Tuesday it was evaluating a final indicative all-cash takeover proposal from Blackstone Europe LLP, which values the warehousing specialist at about 489 million pounds ($633.2 million). ($1 = 0.7723 pounds) ...
Copyright 2023-2026 - www.financetom.com All Rights Reserved