Nov 21 (Reuters) - Investors are on track to withdraw
more money from global climate funds than they deposit this year
for the first time, Morningstar Sustainalytics said on Thursday,
presenting an obstacle to energy-transition efforts.
Net withdrawals from the funds reached nearly $24 billion
for the first nine months of 2024, the arm of Chicago-based
research firm Morningstar ( MORN ) said, compared with net
deposits of $40 billion during the first nine months of 2023.
The funds have recorded net deposits every year since they
were tracked separately in 2018, peaking at $151 billion in
2021. Inflows then fell to $60 billion in 2022 and $40 billion
for 2023, Morningstar Sustainalytics said.
The research firm said the recent outflows reflect factors
such as the poor performance of renewable energy stocks,
concerns about greenwashing, and anti-ESG sentiment.
High interest rates also played a role, said Hortense Bioy,
head of sustainable investing research at Morningstar
Sustainalytics, holding back the performance of growth-oriented
companies involved in areas such as solar power.
"Those are the companies that can be quite sensitive to
interest rates. The financing costs have really weighed on their
valuations in the stock market," Bioy said.
Climate funds' total assets were $572 billion as of Sept.
30, up 6% from the start of the year, driven by market
appreciation. About 85% of those assets were held in
European-domiciled funds, with 6% in China-based funds and 5% in
U.S.-based funds.
Among the climate funds, climate-transition funds that favor
companies better positioned for a low-carbon economy had an
average return of 17.2% through September, versus 12.4% for the
average peer in the global large-cap blend equity category.
Clean energy/tech funds have lagged peers since 2021 and had
a negative return of 3.2% through September.
There were 69 new climate-fund launches through September,
off their 2023 pace when more than 200 were launched over the
full year.