Aug 2 (Reuters) - A Texas state judge on Friday barred
Google from questioning the state and its legal team in their
lawsuit accusing the Alphabet unit of unlawfully
collecting biometric privacy data of millions of Texans without
consent.
In a brief order, Judge Leah Robinson in Midland County said
Google could not compel Texas to submit to a deposition in the
case. Texas had opposed Google's effort to depose the state,
calling it an impermissible effort to "investigate the
investigator."
Google wanted to question Texas over the state's
understanding of key terms in the privacy law at the center of
the 2022 lawsuit, including how liabilities and penalties are
determined. Google said the state had refused to offer a witness
who could talk about the basis of the state's claims and provide
evidence that Google could need for its defense.
Google on Friday declined to comment. The Texas attorney
general's office did not immediately respond to a request for
comment.
Texas in its lawsuit accused Google of deceptive trade
practices and alleged it violated a state law that shields
biometric identifiers such as faces, fingerprints and eye scans
from being captured without approval.
Google unlawfully collected biometric data through Google
Photos, Google Assistant and Nest Hub Max, Texas said. The
privacy law sets out penalties of up to $25,000 per violation.
Google has denied any wrongdoing.
Google told the court in a filing in May that the Texas
biometric privacy law "sat unenforced for its first twenty years
on the books" before the state lodged cases against Google and
Facebook parent Meta in 2022.
Meta this week agreed to pay $1.4 billion to
resolve the Texas lawsuit.
Lawyers for Texas at Keller Postman and McKool Smith said
the settlement was the largest-ever won by a single state. Meta
denied any wrongdoing in agreeing to settle.
The case is Texas v Google LLC, 385th Judicial District
Court, Midland County, No. CV58999.
For Texas: Marc Collier and Joseph Graham Jr of Norton Rose
Fulbright
For Google: R. Paul Yetter of Yetter Coleman; Benedict Hur
and Simona Agnolucci of Willkie Farr & Gallagher
Read more:
Legal Fee Tracker: Texas contracts show law firms' stake in
$1.4 bln Meta settlement
Meta to pay $1.4 billion to settle Texas facial recognition
data lawsuit
Texas fights Google deposition bid in biometric privacy
lawsuit
Texas sues Google for allegedly capturing biometric data of
millions without consent