*
Votes on environmental and social issues get less support
*
Average support halved since 2022 to 16%, Morningstar ( MORN ) says
*
Proxy advisors also cut support, Jasper Street says
By Ross Kerber
July 11 (Reuters) - Support for shareholder resolutions
pressing U.S. companies for environmental and social reforms
fell to 16% on average for the 12 months ended June 30, half the
rate of three years ago, data from Morningstar ( MORN ) shows.
Analysts, activists and investors attributed the trend to
hostility to climate and diversity matters from U.S. President
Donald Trump and other Republicans, coupled with the reforms
many companies have already put in place. Top proxy advisers
also reduced their support.
Most U.S. shareholder meetings have finished for 2025, and
the results show how the pendulum has swung away from
progressive corporate causes, albeit while leaving many recent
changes in place.
ENVIRONMENTAL AND WORKFORCE REPORTING IMPROVES
Large investors seemed reluctant to support resolutions that
might attract questions from customers or political criticism,
said Leslie Samuelrich, president of Green Century, a
climate-focused asset manager.
Its own resolutions calling for reports on greenhouse gas
emissions and biodiversity, for instance, won 13.6% on average
this year, against 21% in 2024.
Samuelrich said big investors "don't want to lose clients,
and they don't want a target on their backs".
Marc Lindsay, managing partner of shareholder advisory firm
Jasper Street, said better company reporting of emissions or
workforce diversity was giving executives ammunition to argue
against the need for further reforms.
"There are simply less disclosure gaps for activists to
attack," Lindsay said.
Donna Anderson, asset manager T Rowe Price's ( TROW ) global
head of corporate governance, said its support for such
resolutions was lower than in 2024, when it backed 8% of
environmental resolutions and 4% of social proposals.
"The sense that shareholders need to support any of these
proposals has waned," Anderson said.
PROXY ADVISERS BACK OFF
Lindsay's firm found top proxy advisers Institutional
Shareholder Services and Glass Lewis each backed environmental
resolutions less often this year, and that ISS backed social
resolutions less often. Both have faced pressure from
Republicans and business groups.
ISS declined to comment.
Glass Lewis said a reason for its lower support may be that
"many U.S. companies now meet baseline environmental
expectations, providing shareholders with visibility into how
related risks are being managed."
Industry tracker Morningstar ( MORN ) found "anti-ESG" resolutions
filed by conservatives to roll back diversity or environmental
efforts won only 2.7% support on average, as in recent years.
Tim Schwarzenberger, portfolio manager for filer Inspire
Investing, blamed the low rate on lack of support from proxy
advisers. But he said companies were often willing to make deals
to have the resolutions withdrawn, a trend pro-ESG groups have
also found.
The deals help companies avoid controversy, Schwarzenberger
said. "They want to avoid any negative PR," he said.