OIAPOQUE, Brazil, April 18 (Reuters) - State-run energy
firm Petrobras has hit growing resistance from Indigenous groups
and government agencies to its premier exploration project,
which would open the most promising part of Brazil's northern
coast to oil drilling.
Environmental agency Ibama denied Petrobras a license for
exploratory drilling offshore in the Foz do Amazonas area last
year, citing possible impacts on Indigenous groups and the
sensitive coastal biome. But a Petrobras appeal for Ibama to
reverse its decision has drawn powerful political backing.
President Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva said in September that
Brazil should be able to "research" the region's potential
resources, given the national interest. Energy Minister
Alexandre Silveira last week told journalists that it is
"Brazil's right to know the potential" of the offshore fields.
That has bolstered bullish rhetoric from Petrobras about its
chances of getting a license to drill in the blocks off the
coast of Amapa state.
"Get ready Amapa, because we are arriving," Petrobras CEO
Jean Paul Prates told local politicians and oil executives at an
event last month promoting offshore exploration along the
northern coast in an area known as Equatorial Margin. He called
it "perhaps the last frontier of the oil era for Brazil."
He has said he expects to start drilling in the second half
of this year or sooner in the most promising part of the
Equatorial Margin, named the Foz do Amazonas basin, for the
mouth of the Amazon River several hundred kilometers away. Foz
de Amazonas shares geology with the coast of nearby Guyana,
where Exxon is developing huge fields.
Ibama chief Rodrigo Agostinho said in November that a
decision would be made in early 2024, although labor disputes at
the agency have since slowed the pace of environmental
licensing.
Visits to four Indigenous villages, interviews with over a
dozen local leaders, and previously unreported documents show
organized opposition mounting to Petrobras' attempt to reverse
the halt on exploratory drilling.
Petrobras has drawn fresh government scrutiny. Indigenous
affairs agency Funai asked Ibama regulators in December to run
several more studies to assess impacts, according to a Dec. 11
government memo from Funai to Ibama obtained in a freedom of
information request. The proposed studies would have to be done
before Ibama can decide whether to accept the Petrobras appeal.
In July 2022, the Council of Chieftains of the Indigenous
People of Oiapoque (CCPIO), an umbrella group representing more
than 60 Indigenous villages in the area, asked federal
prosecutors to get involved, denouncing an alleged violation of
their rights.
Brazilian prosecutors have a mandate to protect Indigenous
peoples, often taking their side in disputes with firms or
federal and state governments. In September 2022 they
recommended that Ibama not issue the license before a formal
consultation of the local communities.
Records from the prosecutors' preliminary investigation,
seen by Reuters, show that in December 2023, CCPIO asked them to
broker a 13-month formal consultation with Petrobras about
Indigenous views on the project.
The consultation process, along with studies proposed by
Funai, would push a decision into 2025 when Brazil will host the
COP30 climate change summit in the Amazon ( AMZN ) city of Belem,
which could make it more politically difficult to approve
drilling, a person close to CCPIO told Reuters.
Minutes from a June 2023 meeting between Petrobras, CCPIO
leaders and prosecutors show the company offered to consult
local communities about eventual commercial oil production in
the area, if Ibama requests it, but did not commit to a
consultation before drilling exploratory wells.
Asked about Indigenous leaders' calls for immediate
consultations, Petrobras told Reuters in a statement that the
time for such requests has passed.
"The definition of whether or not it is necessary to consult
indigenous peoples and/or traditional communities takes place at
the initial stage of the environmental licensing process,"
Petrobras said.
Ibama has not yet replied to the recommendation by
Indigenous affairs agency Funai late last year for more
assessments of the effects of Petrobras' exploration plans,
according to an April 3 Funai document seen by Reuters.
Both agencies did not reply to requests for comment by
Reuters. CCPIO and prosecutors said a consultation must be made
before Ibama issues a license to drill.
FAULT LINES
The drilling standoff has created a fault line in Lula's
government, which is balancing his vows to protect the Amazon ( AMZN )
and its Indigenous people with the interests of Petrobras and
political allies that stand to reap the benefits of a new
oil-producing region.
Silveira, the energy minister, has said that a single Foz de
Amazonas block off the coast of Amapa state could yield more
than 5.6 billion barrels of oil, which would be the company's
biggest discovery in over a decade.
In its appeal to Ibama, the company said that exploration
will have no negative impact on local communities.
"We ratify the understanding that there is no direct impact
of the temporary activity of drilling a well 175 km from the
coast on Indigenous communities," Petrobras said.
Local people and some environmentalists warn that drilling
could threaten coastal mangroves and vast wetlands rich with
fish and plant life, while disrupting the lives of the 8,000
Indigenous people in Oiapoque, on Brazil's far northern
coast.
The CCPIO, the highest Indigenous authority in Oiapoque, is
composed of more than 60 caciques, or chieftains, representing
over 8,000 people. They do not oppose the search for oil per se,
but invoke what they say is a right to prior consultation by
Petrobras, with supervision from the federal prosecutors' office
and Funai.
The International Labor Organization convention 169, which
Brazil signed, says that governments must consult Indigenous and
tribal peoples through their representative institutions,
whenever considering legislative or administrative measures that
may affect them directly.
CHANGE AFOOT
The plans to drill are already changing Oiapoque. Waves of
migrant workers have arrived looking for jobs in an oil industry
that does not yet exist, state lawmaker Inacio Monteiro said.
Monteiro said he meets often with Indigenous constituents,
talking to them about the benefits that Petrobras could bring to
Oiapoque, including jobs, tax revenue and social programs.
Yet CCPIO and its allies have become increasingly vocal with
their resistance as Petrobras garners support for its appeal,
including at the COP28 climate summit in December, where Luene
Karipuna told a panel that Petrobras and local politicians had
tried to silence her people.
"Strategically, this prior consultation is our only safety
net," 25-year-old Karipuna, who is studying to be a teacher,
said near her home in the Santa Izabel village, where marshes
fill with seawater at certain times of the year.
When the rivers run low, tides bring in saltwater fish the
villagers eat, but some interviewed by Reuters fear it could
just as easily bring oil spills.
POLITICAL PRESSURE
Indigenous leaders said a full-court press from local
politicians in support of Petrobras was on display at a May 2023
public hearing that Monteiro, the state lawmaker, called just
days after Petrobras' license was denied.
Amapa's political powerbrokers, including key Lula allies,
rallied within days at Oiapoque's town hall for the hearing to
promote Petrobras' plans to drill.
At the event, one man in a white polo shirt and a feathered
headdress, Ramon Karipuna told the crowd that Indigenous people
were in favor of drilling, according to minutes of the meeting
seen by Reuters.
Karipuna said he spoke for the coordinator of the CCPIO
council of chieftains, who was absent for "health reasons."
Petrobras later cited Karipuna's endorsement in its appeal
of the denied drilling license and described him as a "CCPIO
representative."
However, CCPIO coordinator Cacique Edmilson Oliveira told
Reuters he was not sick that day. CCPIO had refused to take part
in the hastily summoned event, according to a May 18 letter sent
in response to Monteiro's invitation to the hearing and seen by
Reuters.
"This is very concerning. That's why we are saying that we
already feel threatened," Oliveira said, accusing Petrobras of
distorting the views of Indigenous leaders. "We never sat down
and reached an agreement for approval."
In a telephone interview, Karipuna confirmed he worked at
the town hall and that he is not a member of CCPIO - even though
Petrobras used his words as its main argument to Ibama that
Indigenous representatives supported drilling. He also backed
away from his comments in favor of drilling.
"To this day many people have doubts about this Petrobras
business," he said.
Asked about its mischaracterization of Karipuna, Petrobras
cited the minutes of the May 2023 meeting, without elaborating.