*
$TRUMP was listed in an average of 4 days by exchanges, vs
129
days for other big coins
*
Three crypto exchanges say they moved to list $TRUMP fast
because of customer demand
*
Exchanges say no corners were cut in vetting the coin for
listing
*
White House says Trump coin poses 'no conflicts of
interest'
By Hannah Lang, Elizabeth Howcroft, Michelle Conlin, Medha
Singh
NEW YORK, July 14 (Reuters) - Crypto exchange Coinbase
assures users on its website that it puts any new digital coin
through "rigorous" vetting before allowing it to trade. It's an
at-times lengthy process meant to protect customers by examining
the people connected to the project and the risk of market
manipulation or other scams.
With President Donald Trump's crypto token, $TRUMP, Coinbase
made up its mind in just one day.
The $TRUMP token, which launched three days before his
inauguration in January, is a meme coin. Based on cultural fads
or celebrities, these coins have no intrinsic value and - past
experience has shown - are prone to large price swings that can
leave investors with losses.
A Reuters analysis of crypto market data and industry
announcements found that, compared to other recent large meme
coins, the biggest crypto exchanges took Trump's to market with
unusual speed, despite stating they vet risky coins thoroughly
to protect small investors.
Some also approved the listing in spite of the high share of
coins concentrated in the hands of Trump and his partners, which
would normally represent a red flag because of the risk that
dumping of tokens by insiders could collapse the price and hurt
other investors, some executives said.
After reaching an all-time high of $75.35 on April 19, just
two days after its launch, $TRUMP crashed to the $7 range by
early April, leaving many holders nursing losses. It was trading
around $9.55 Thursday.
"When the president of the United States launches a meme
coin, I thought I might as well put some money inside," said
Carl "Moon" Runefelt, a Dubai-based crypto investor who runs a
bitcoin trading channel on YouTube called the "Moon Show."
Runefelt said he bought $300,000 worth of the meme coin in
tranches at between $50 and $60: "It's probably one of my worst
trades, unfortunately."
The Reuters analysis showed that eight of the 10 largest
crypto exchanges by market share listed the coin within 48 hours
of its release. The ninth, Coinbase, added $TRUMP to its
listings roadmap on January 18 - indicating it had decided to
accept it - and listed the coin three days later. The tenth,
Upbit, listed $TRUMP on February 13.
That was much faster than they've done on average with the
biggest meme coins.
Reuters examined how long it took the same 10 exchanges -
Binance, Gate.io, Bitget, MEXC, OKX, Coinbase, Bybit, Upbit,
Crypto.com and HTX - to list the four other largest meme coins
launched since 2022.
These, measured by market cap on May 29, are Pepe, Bonk,
Fartcoin and dogwifhat. All 10 exchanges listed Pepe and Bonk.
Nine listed dogwifhat, and seven listed Fartcoin.
On average, the 10 exchanges took 129 days to list those
coins. For $TRUMP, they took an average of four.
Asked for comment about why they listed $TRUMP so quickly,
Bitget, MEXC, OKX, Coinbase and Upbit all said they had not cut
any corners with their vetting process. The other five exchanges
did not respond to Reuters' questions.
Three - Bitget, Coinbase, MEXC - said they moved fast to
respond to overwhelming demand for the $TRUMP coin.
"The crypto space was buzzing with the hype and, as any
other token with a growing craze, it was imperative to add
TRUMP," Gracy Chen, Bitget's CEO, said in a statement.
Chen said the fact that Trump himself announced the coin on
his social media accounts "should kind of solve the compliance
issue," citing the fact that "he's the president of the United
States."
'NO CONFLICTS OF INTEREST'
Reuters found no suggestion that Trump or anyone related to
his businesses exerted pressure on the exchanges. In response to
a request for comment, a White House press official told Reuters
the president's assets had been placed in a family trust: "There
are no conflicts of interest because the president isn't
managing the assets. Any insinuation that there is a conflict of
interest is irresponsible."
The official referred specific questions about the meme coin
to the Trump Organization, which did not respond to Reuters.
Coinbase said the $TRUMP token got no special exceptions and
the exchange followed its normal process when listing the coin.
Paul Grewal, Coinbase's chief legal officer, said many people
had to work over the weekend to get the listing done quickly,
but no steps were skipped.
"Given the information that was shared publicly, we were
confident that users could engage with the token positively and
safely," Grewal told Reuters.
Coinbase listed $TRUMP as an "experimental" token to
indicate it comes with "certain risks, including price swings,"
according to the company's website.
The vetting of coins often focuses on how well-known the
issuer is, how likely they are to remain in the public eye and
how much they engage with the online community to sustain
interest in the coin, metrics that $TRUMP would score highly on,
according to Santa Clara University finance professor Seoyoung
Kim, who specializes in crypto analytics.
She cautioned that focusing on vetting speed alone could
provide an incomplete picture of investor protection.
A more holistic analysis, Kim said, would also involve
factors such as the average market cap at which a coin is
listed, for how long it has sustained that level before its
listing, and its daily trading volumes.
With $TRUMP listed so soon after launch, there was little
such data for exchanges to parse. $TRUMP's market cap has since
fallen to around $1.9 billion, down sharply from its peak above
$15 billion on January 19. But that still ranks it amongst the
largest meme coins launched since 2022.
Reuters ran its listing-speed analysis past five academics
with crypto expertise, including Kim, who all said its
methodology was sound.
David Krause, Emeritus Professor of Finance at Marquette
University, who has studied Trump's crypto ventures, said the
quickness of the $TRUMP listing "suggests either a dramatic
acceleration of due diligence or corners being cut."
"Either scenario has significant implications for investor
protection and market integrity," he said.
YOU DON'T SAY NO TO THE PRESIDENT
The president's rush of business ventures in a
lightly-regulated sector that his government is responsible for
overseeing has drawn criticism from Democrats, consumer advocacy
groups and former financial enforcement officials.
"You don't say no to hosting the president's new meme coin,"
said Corey Frayer, a former senior crypto advisor at the U.S.
Securities and Exchange Commission. Frayer is now director of a
non-profit advocacy group, the Consumer Federation of America.
"The president controls who oversees your business and how they
enforce the law."
Under former President Joe Biden, the SEC maintained that
most crypto tokens, including meme coins, should be regulated as
securities, making exchanges cautious about listing them. That
began to change, quickly, after Trump was elected last
November.
The Republican has styled himself as the "crypto president,"
pledging to overhaul regulation of the sector. Following Trump's
election, Coinbase - the largest publicly traded crypto exchange
in the United States - and several of its rivals began listing
more meme coins.
In Trump's second term, the SEC has paused or withdrawn
high-profile enforcement actions against crypto operators,
including a major investor in a Trump family crypto project, and
issued a staff statement concluding that meme coins do not
constitute securities.
An SEC spokesperson declined to comment on the agency's
crypto policy and Trump's coin.
Trump's family has launched multiple crypto ventures, raking
in hundreds of millions of dollars. The $TRUMP token quickly
earned an estimated $320 million in fees, though it's not
publicly known how that amount has been divided between a
Trump-controlled entity and its partners.
OVERLOOKED CONCERNS
Exchanges have been major beneficiaries of Trump's embrace
of the industry. $TRUMP has generated significant revenue for
the 10 exchanges in Reuters' review: more than $172 million in
trading fees, according to estimates based on standard fees
compiled for the news agency by CoinDesk Data, a crypto industry
data provider.
Trade in the coin, meanwhile, has favored a small group of
investors.
At the top, 45 crypto wallets cleared about $1.2 billion in
profits overall, while another 712,777 wallets have collectively
lost $4.3 billion, according to trading data analyzed by crypto
analysis firm Bubblemaps as of June 18. In the middle, more than
half a million wallets made an average of $5,656 profit each.
In listing $TRUMP, some exchanges proceeded despite a factor
they'd previously labelled as a red flag: 80% of the coin's
supply was held by the Trump family and its partners. Such a
high concentration of ownership can allow the team behind a coin
to sell large amounts of it at once, collapsing the price for
retail investors. The terms of the $TRUMP coin specified that
its total supply would be gradually unlocked over three years
after initial release.
On January 16, the day before $TRUMP was released, the New
York State Department of Financial Services issued an alert to
consumers about the risks of meme coins. Such coins, the notice
said, are carried by platforms not licensed by the state and the
supply of the digital tokens is often controlled by a small
number of people.
That opens the door to "pump-and-dump schemes," the
regulator noted, in which public hype by their issuers leads to
a jump in price - with big, early investors exiting and smaller
retail buyers left holding the losses that follow.
The NYDFS declined to comment beyond the guidance.
Coinbase, which is subject to New York regulations, blocked
state residents from accessing the token, but allowed U.S.
customers elsewhere to trade. To list $TRUMP in New York, the
exchange would have faced a long list of risk assessment and
governance requirements.
Some other exchanges acknowledged they looked past concerns
about the concentration in a bid to serve customer demand.
MEXC's chief operating officer, Tracy Jin, told Reuters
that, because of the concentration of tokens, $TRUMP did not
meet its usual standards for a full listing on its main board,
but the exchange pushed ahead anyway due to strong demand.
In a follow-up written statement, an MEXC spokesperson said
that a "faster-than-usual" listing was possible because the coin
had clear market momentum and it met "our listing standards
early." Commenting on the Reuters listing-speed analysis, the
spokesperson said market conditions and demand for political
meme tokens had changed since 2022, "making direct comparisons
less relevant."
Bitget also had concerns about the 80% figure, CEO Chen told
Reuters.
"Eighty percent held by the team, even though there's a
little bit of a lock-up period, is in my opinion very risky,"
said Chen. "Ultimately, user trading volume, demand ... overrode
the so-called risky factor here."
Like some exchanges, Bitget, based in the Seychelles, does
not have a business presence in the U.S. or serve clients who
reside there, Chen said. "Globally," she added, "people are
generally aware of the risks associated with trading meme
coins."
Upbit, which operates in South Korea, said it does not
comment on specific coin listings but that it has "a rigorous
and comprehensive evaluation process."
Erald Ghoos, CEO for Europe of OKX, said the exchange's
legal and compliance teams stayed up all night over different
time zones to work on the listing.
Seychelles-registered OKX says its diligence process
requires "meticulous preparation." It decided to list $TRUMP
within 26 hours.
(Editing by Tom Lasseter, Tommy Reggiori Wilkes, Paritosh
Bansal, and Daniel Flynn)