*
Bangladeshi drugs made with Ozempic key ingredient shipped
to 12
markets, including U.S. and Britain - data
*
Novo Nordisk says it cannot vouch for safety of unapproved
semaglutide-based products
*
Patent exemptions allow companies in Bangladesh and Laos
to
produce semaglutide drugs
*
Some Chinese ingredient makers have started to produce
semaglutide
By Andrew Silver
SHANGHAI, Nov 1 (Reuters) - Just over a year ago, New
Zealand customs officials started to intercept batches of
injectable medications labelled Fitaro and Orsema, developed by
a little-known Bangladeshi drugmaker, Incepta Pharmaceuticals.
The injectable pens, 14 of which were seized at the border,
contained semaglutide, a patented substance that helps control
blood sugar levels and appetite and is the key ingredient in
Novo Nordisk's blockbuster drugs Ozempic and Wegovy,
according to data from New Zealand's medicines regulator
Medsafe, reviewed by Reuters.
The Incepta drugs are part of an Asia-based supply chain
manufacturing and exporting cheaper copies of Ozempic across the
world, Reuters has found, driven by a spike in global demand for
the drug.
Ozempic was developed for type 2 diabetes but its active
ingredient semaglutide is effective in promoting weight loss.
The market for such weight-loss treatments, which Novo Nordisk
is targeting with anti-obesity treatment Wegovy, is forecast to
reach $150 billion by the early 2030s.
According to a Reuters review, at least 106,000 packs of
semaglutide-based medicines made in Asia by Incepta have been
shipped to 12 foreign markets including countries like the
United States and Britain where Ozempic is protected by patents.
Incepta did not respond to multiple requests for comment
about Fitaro and Orsema, which are approved for sale in
Bangladesh, according to public records and information provided
by a local regulatory official. The official with the
Bangladesh Directorate General of Drug Administration, who
declined to be named because he was not authorized to speak to
the media, said Bangladeshi regulators had given Incepta
permission to export Fitaro or Orsema but only provided it had
won approval from receiving countries. The injectable pens,
which are not authorised for use in New Zealand, were referred
to Medsafe between August 2023 and May 2024 and destroyed, data
from the regulator showed.
Medsafe told Reuters the Fitaro and Orsema batches that were
destroyed appeared to be for personal use but did not comment on
whether the medicines carried any health risk.
"Medicines that have been imported from overseas will not have
been assessed and approved by Medsafe, so carry a significant
risk as there is no assurance they have been made to an
acceptable level of quality," the regulator added in response to
a Reuters query about imports of semaglutide-based drugs.
Reuters has previously reported that semaglutide drugs from
Bangladesh were sold on India-based online marketplace
IndiaMART. The latest reporting shows that the international
distribution of semaglutide drugs not made by Novo Nordisk is
much wider.
The data surveyed by Reuters came from pharmaceutical regulators
in Australia, Brazil, New Zealand and the United States;
information from a commercial customs data provider for Kenya,
Uzbekistan, Venezuela, Hong Kong and the United Arab Emirates;
and records of intercepted drugs from Britain, Switzerland and
Ireland.
In addition, an interview with a trade show exhibitor, a review
of data from the commercial customs data provider, and from
Brazil's Justice Ministry showed that six little-known
companies, four of which are based in Asia, manufacture
semaglutide-based medicines and that their products are shipped
overseas.
At least three of these firms imported the key ingredient
from China and at least one of their products was promoted
online and in person outside the country of origin, according to
the commercial customs data provider's data, an interview with
an employee at Chinese supplier Nanjing Hanxin Pharmaceutical
Technology, and a website and social media app reviewed by
Reuters.
These players take advantage of global patent exemptions allowed
for less developed countries and instances of loose patent
enforcement in countries including in China, the Reuters review
shows.
Novo Nordisk told Reuters it is the only approved
manufacturer of semaglutide globally, and it could not vouch for
the safety or effectiveness of products claiming to contain
semaglutide made by other manufacturers.
Even though Novo Nordisk's semaglutide is protected by
international licences, countries like Bangladesh and Laos,
classified as least developed nations by the United Nations,
enjoy exemptions from industry patent rules.
The Danish firm, which has quickly become Europe's most
valuable company with a market capitalisation of around $400
billion, states on its website that it does not enforce patents
in less developed countries. Given the frenzied demand for
Ozempic, the financial impact of possible patent infringement on
Novo Nordisk is currently limited. "Illegal versions of the
drugs today do not cannibalize Novo's sales given they are
selling every dose they can produce," said Nicholas Anderson,
portfolio manager and managing director at global asset
management firm Thornburg Investment Management, which owns Novo
Nordisk stocks.
However, such copies are raising healthcare concerns. Medicines
regulators in at least six countries including the U.S., Britain
and Ireland have rejected, destroyed or seized some of Incepta's
semaglutide-based drugs, according to drug regulator records and
responses from regulators to Reuters' queries. In one case,
unauthorised semaglutide was recalled in South Africa in
December, because of potential health risks, according to a
public notice posted in January by the local medicines
regulator. The authority told Reuters the ingredient was sourced
from a supplier in China not authorised to produce the
ingredient in Ozempic, without providing more details.
"The semaglutide, said to be found in this unauthorised
substance, may contain unexpected impurities or degradation
products which can have unknown effects on patients," the notice
said.
Reuters found no evidence that these products would have caused
any harm to patients, but their spread could add to public
health concerns about a sector also threatened by fake
Ozempic.
PARALLEL SUPPLY CHAIN
The official with the Bangladesh Directorate General of Drug
Administration said Orsema was approved in Bangladesh and
considered safe. Fitaro is also approved for sale, public
records show.
A clinic in the capital Dhaka has prescribed Incepta's Fitaro
injector pens to around 20 patients, all foreigners based in
Bangladesh, according to a manager, who declined to be named or
identify the clinic due to the sensitivity around the treatment.
"When patients found out that Fitaro was available in
Bangladesh at a maximum monthly cost of around $60 a month,
(against) $650 in the U.S. (for Wegovy), they didn't seem
particularly focused on who the manufacturer was," the manager
said. In Laos, semaglutide-based medicines can only be
legally produced and distributed for national use, Davone
Duangdany, director of the drug and medical device control
division within the Laos health ministry, told Reuters. But
some Chinese companies have been promoting Laos-produced
semaglutide tablets in China, where Novo Nordisk's patent is due
to expire in 2026 or earlier if it loses a legal challenge. At
an industry exhibition in Shanghai in June that Reuters
attended, ingredient manufacturer Nanjing Hanxin Pharmaceutical
Technology displayed boxes of Semagcare semaglutide tablets,
manufactured by Laos-based Boten Elemento Pharma.
Abdu Zoghbi, business development director of Nanjing Hanxin,
told Reuters that his company provides semaglutide to the
Laos-based drugmaker.
"We don't know which countries (Semagcare is sold to) but
we are doing the promotion because once they sell more, we sell
more API (active pharmaceutical ingredient) to them," he told
Reuters when asked about why it was showcasing the drug at the
expo.
Boten Elemento Pharma's Semagcare tablets appeared on sale
on a Chinese language website and also a Chinese social media
app, according to a Reuters review. Sales of semaglutide by a
Chinese company could amount to an infringement of Novo
Nordisk's China patent, said Frank Yang, senior associate at
Marks & Clerk Intellectual Property Agency in reply to a Reuters
query about possible licences breaches.
A spokeswoman for Novo Nordisk said the company does not
produce the ingredient in China.
The China National Intellectual Property Administration
declared the Danish drugmaker's patent invalid in September
2022. However, Novo Nordisk successfully appealed this decision.
Novo Nordisk told Reuters it is now awaiting a court
decision on a subsequent appeal.
"We hope to see a continued trend in supporting and protecting
innovation during patent invalidation proceedings," a Novo
Nordisk spokesperson said in response to questions about whether
it was enforcing its patent in China.
Contacted by Reuters by fax, the Chinese medicine regulator did
not reply to queries about quality controls at the Chinese firms
making semaglutide.
A second Chinese firm, Shanghai Longtide Biotechnology,
which described itself as a biotechnology company, also
displayed a box of Semagcare tablets at its booth at a separate
trade show in Shenzhen that Reuters also attended. Reuters
contacted Boten Elemento Pharma through its website but the
company did not respond. A business registered as Shanghai
Longtide Biotechnology did not reply to requests for comment.
BENDING BOUNDARIES A third Chinese biotechnology
firm, Zhejiang Peptites Biotech, is among the suppliers of
semaglutide to Incepta, the data from the commercial customs
data provider showed. The Bangladeshi drugmaker has
imported at least 892 grams of semaglutide valued at about
$805,000 between 2020 and 2024 from mainland China and Hong
Kong, according to a Reuters calculation based on the customs
data provider's shipment data for Zhejiang Peptites Biotech and
other suppliers. Zhejiang Peptites Biotech also supplied at
least 25.6 kg of semaglutide, valued about $2.8 million, to
Russian drugmaker Geropharm in 2023 and 2024, according to
Reuters calculations based on the customs data provider's data.
Geropharm can use inventions protected by Russian patents to
provide semaglutide-based medication to the local population
without Novo's consent until the end of December, according to a
Russian government decree issued in December 2023.
The Russian company said Zhejiang Peptites Biotech's supply
of semaglutide is carried out in accordance with a contract and
it does not export the finished drug, Semavic, abroad.
However, Semavic was exported from Russia multiple times to
the breakaway Georgian region of Abkhazia, information from the
commercial customs data provider reviewed by Reuters showed.
Zhejiang Peptites Biotech did not respond to a request for
comment on shipments of semaglutide to Incepta and Geropharm.
The customs data showed that it was not only Chinese firms
supplying semaglutide: Incepta has imported the ingredient from
Swiss generic drugmaker Bachem. A spokesperson for
Bachem said it produces semaglutide for pharmaceutical companies
for research and development purposes only and declined to
comment on its relationship with Incepta. Medicines
regulator Swissmedic told Reuters Bachem was authorised to
export semaglutide, but added Swissmedic was "not supervising
patents".