*
Changes affect access to MMRV shots
*
Hepatitis B, COVID-19 vaccine votes expected on Friday
*
Vote raises questions about vaccine coverage
By Michael Erman, Julie Steenhuysen and Mariam Sunny
ATLANTA, Sept 18 (Reuters) - U.S. vaccine advisers voted
on Thursday to revise the use of one of two key childhood
vaccines under review, another step in U.S. Health Secretary
Robert F. Kennedy's push to rewrite U.S. immunization policy.
The group, which advises the Centers for Disease Control and
Prevention on U.S. vaccination schedules, recommended against
allowing parents to choose the combined
measles-mumps-rubella-varicella vaccine before age 4.
Instead, separate vaccine shots will be given for
measles-mumps-rubella and varicella.
The votes are the first from Kennedy's 12-member Advisory
Committee on Immunization Practices, many of whom have advocated
against vaccine use. Five of those members were named this week.
Kennedy, a longtime anti-vaccine activist, is moving at
breakneck speed to push through changes to the nation's vaccine
policies, including restricting eligibility to COVID-19 shots,
ousting the country's top public health official, and amplifying
federal support for state vaccine exemptions.
He says these moves are needed to restore trust in U.S.
public health agencies.
The panel delayed to Friday a vote on a recommendation to wait
to give the hepatitis B vaccine until infants reach 1 month of
age, rather than at birth, unless the mother tests positive for
the virus.
A spokesperson for Merck ( MRK ), which makes the combination MMRV
shot, said the recent advisory committee vote and discussion
"occurred in the absence of new scientific data and in contrast
to years of evidence affirming the current immunization
schedule."
PANEL SAYS MOVE ADDRESSES FEBRILE SEIZURE RISK
The panel reviewed the change to the combined MMRV shot
recommendation based on studies showing a higher risk of
seizures in children under 4 compared with those who received
separate measles-mumps-rubella and varicella shots.
The CDC had already recommended separate MMR and varicella
vaccines for children younger than 4 unless parents express a
preference for the combined shot.
The day-long meeting was marked by points of confusion as
an entirely new roster of members asked about procedures and the
impact of their decisions on health insurance coverage.
The panel repeatedly asked for clarification on the vote
for coverage under the Vaccines for Children program, forcing
one panel member to abstain because it was not clear what he was
voting on.
The split vote appeared to allow children covered under the
Vaccines for Children to continue to have free access to the
combination shot, but the new recommendations could limit access
to the combination shot for other children.
The Merck ( MRK ) spokesperson described the vote on the children's
vaccine program as unprecedented and said it was still working
to figure out the implications to access.
"It's confusing. They're going to need to clarify this,"
said Dr. Norman Baylor, former director of the FDA's Office of
Vaccines Research and Review who has served as a liaison to the
vaccine panel.
"I'm just amazed that nobody stepped up to say, take a step
back," Dr. Bruce Gellin, former HHS deputy assistant secretary
for Health and director of the National Vaccine Program Office,
said. "If this is going to invoke trust, we've got a long way to
go."
During the meeting, several committee members objected to
the absence of representatives of physician groups and experts
who administer vaccines and changes in standard protocols for
reviewing and ranking evidence before taking votes.
Such representatives were removed from work group
participation, where such discussions typically occur, and no
such work groups were convened to consider the data on either
the MMRV or hepatitis B shot.
Dr. Aaron Milstone, pediatric director of Infection
Prevention at Johns Hopkins Children's Center, said afterwards
the move would reduce access to vaccines and remove the ability
of parents to decide to give the child fewer shots.
The committee is expected to vote on Friday on
recommendations on who should get the COVID-19 vaccine.