financetom
Business
financetom
/
Business
/
Legal Fee Tracker: Meta case yields Texas-size fees as more firms ink state contracts
News World Market Environment Technology Personal Finance Politics Retail Business Economy Cryptocurrency Forex Stocks Market Commodities
Legal Fee Tracker: Meta case yields Texas-size fees as more firms ink state contracts
Dec 12, 2024 10:53 AM

Dec 12 (Reuters) - Texas' appetite for litigation has

been keeping several law firms busy working for the state in

high-profile lawsuits against major U.S. companies.

Chicago-founded Keller Postman and Dallas-founded McKool

Smith billed the Texas attorney general's office a combined

$142.6 million last month for their work on the state's 2022

consumer privacy lawsuit against Facebook parent Meta Platforms ( META )

, documents show. The case led to a $1.4 billion

settlement with Meta in July.

McKool Smith and Keller Postman contracted with the state to

spearhead the lawsuit in exchange for a cut of a successful

recovery. The requested payout - $93.3 million for Keller

Postman and $42.6 million for McKool Smith - works out to an

average of $3,100 per hour for 42,600 hours the firms combined

said they invested in the case.

Zina Bash, a Keller Postman partner and former senior

counsel to Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton, in a statement

called the Meta accord the "largest settlement achievement by a

single state in U.S. history."

It isn't uncommon for states to hire private law firms to

handle large, complex cases using contingency contracts. In the

case of Texas, Paxton's office has signed outside counsel

contracts with at least 15 law firms since 2018, according to

state records.

Tapping attorneys from Mark Lanier's Lanier Law Firm and

Kelley Drye & Warren, Texas on Wednesday sued 3M, Corteva and

DuPont for allegedly concealing health and environmental risks

of toxic PFAS "forever chemicals."

Paxton said the state is "taking action to penalize these

companies and hold them accountable for deceiving Texans into

buying consumer products without vital information." The

companies did not immediately respond to requests for comment.

"We are honored to bring our expertise to this arena as

well," Lanier said in an email. Lawyers at Kelley Drye did not

immediately respond to a request for comment.

Texas's contracts with outside counsel are governed by state

law that protects against unreasonable fees, a spokesperson for

Paxton's office said.

Last month Texas turned to outside counsel to sue asset

managers BlackRock, Vanguard and State Street for allegedly

violating antitrust law and driving up energy prices through

climate activism. BlackRock and State Street have called the

lawsuit baseless. Vanguard did not respond to a request for

comment.

Contracts with Paxton's office show that Tony Buzbee's

Buzbee Law Firm and Cooper & Kirk stand to receive success fees

of up to $3,780 per hour or 10% of Texas' potential recovery in

the case.

Other firms with open contracts with the state include

Norton Rose Fulbright, which Texas hired in January 2022 for a

biometric privacy lawsuit against Alphabet's Google.

Like the settled case against Meta, the lawsuit claims Google

unlawfully collected the biometric privacy data of millions of

Texans without their consent. Google has denied wrongdoing.

Norton Rose Fulbright's 2022 agreement with Texas shows it

could collect as much as $3,780 an hour or 27% of any successful

recovery. Norton Rose partners representing the state did not

immediately respond to a request for comment.

--DaVita Inc ( DVA ) on Monday said in court papers that it has reached

a settlement in principle in a dispute over attorney fees with a

former company executive who blew the whistle on the company's

alleged violation of federal anti-kickback laws.

DaVita ( DVA ) in July paid $34.4 million to the U.S. government to

settle claims that it violated the False Claims Act by paying

kickbacks to doctors in exchange for referring their patients to

the company's dialysis centers. DaVita ( DVA ) made no admission of

liability.

Dennis Kogod, a DaVita ( DVA ) executive who sued the company under

the FCA's whistleblower provision, received an award of $6.37

million from the federal government, the Justice Department

said.

Kogod and his lawyers at Constantine Cannon also sought

$14.1 million in attorney fees from DaVita ( DVA ), arguing they are

entitled to fees after spending more than 30,000 hours

litigating the case.

DaVita's ( DVA ) lawyers at Sidley Austin countered that the

company's settlement only involved a "small subset" of Kogod's

claims. The company also said Kogod's fee demand "reflects a

lack of any reasonable billing judgment."

In their joint Tuesday filing, DaVita ( DVA ) and Kogod said they

were still finalizing the settlement terms but were expecting to

finish by Dec. 31. They asked U.S. District Judge Philip Brimmer

to pause the case proceedings until Jan. 10.

Lawyers for Kogod and DaVita ( DVA ) did not immediately respond to

requests for comment.

(Legal Fee Tracker is a weekly feature exploring attorney

compensation awards and disputes in class actions, bankruptcies

and other matters. Please send tips or suggestions to

[email protected].)

Read More:

Legal Fee Tracker: Ex-judge sues law firm Hagens Berman over

pharma fee award

Legal Fee Tracker: China's Irico faces fee award plus

damages in price-fixing case

Legal Fee Tracker: 3M earplug settlement lawyers inch closer

to $540 mln payout

Comments
Welcome to financetom comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
Related Articles >
Exclusive-Musk's SpaceX is building spy satellite network for US intelligence agency, sources say
Exclusive-Musk's SpaceX is building spy satellite network for US intelligence agency, sources say
Mar 16, 2024
WASHINGTON (Reuters) - SpaceX is building a network of hundreds of spy satellites under a classified contract with a U.S. intelligence agency, five sources familiar with the program said, demonstrating deepening ties between billionaire entrepreneur Elon Musk's space company and national security agencies. The network is being built by SpaceX's Starshield business unit under a $1.8 billion contract signed in...
Canadian payments processor Nuvei nears buyout deal, WSJ reports
Canadian payments processor Nuvei nears buyout deal, WSJ reports
Mar 16, 2024
March 16 (Reuters) - Private equity firm Advent International is in advanced talks with Canadian payments processor Nuvei ( NVEI ) for a transaction that could be announced soon, the Wall Street Journal reported on Saturday citing people familiar with the matter. The talks could still fall apart before a deal is reached, the report added. ...
Advent near deal to buy Canadian payments processor Nuvei, source says
Advent near deal to buy Canadian payments processor Nuvei, source says
Mar 16, 2024
March 16 (Reuters) - Private equity firm Advent International is in advanced talks to buy Canadian payments processor Nuvei ( NVEI ), a source familiar with the matter told Reuters on Saturday. A deal between the parties could be announced soon, said the source, who asked not to be named because the discussions are confidential. The Wall Street Journal first...
BRIEF-Canadian Payments Processor Nuvei Is Nearing A Buyout Deal - WSJ
BRIEF-Canadian Payments Processor Nuvei Is Nearing A Buyout Deal - WSJ
Mar 16, 2024
March 16 (Reuters) - * CANADIAN PAYMENTS PROCESSOR NUVEI IS NEARING A BUYOUT DEAL - WSJ Source text: tinyurl.com/26txuoc3 Further company coverage: ...
Copyright 2023-2026 - www.financetom.com All Rights Reserved