WASHINGTON, May 6 (Reuters) - Israel's NSO Group was
handed a $168 million penalty by a federal jury in California on
Tuesday for hijacking the servers of WhatsApp in order to hack
users of the Meta-owned chat platform on behalf of
foreign spy agencies. The case caps a six-year battle between
the American social media giant and the surveillance firm. It
has also cast a unusual amount of light on the inner workings of
the spyware industry.
Here is what we have learned:
TOP-SHELF SPYWARE IS NOT CHEAP
Between 2018 and 2020 NSO charged its European government
customers a "standard price" of $7 million for use of its
platform to hack 15 different devices at a time, according to
Sarit Bizinsky Gil, NSO's vice president of global business
operations. The executive said the ability to hack a phone
outside the customer's country was a separate add-on worth
approximately $1 million or $2 million.
"It is a highly sophisticated product," Meta lawyer Antonio
Perez told the court in his opening statement, "And it carries a
hefty price tag."
NSO HACKED THOUSANDS OF DEVICES
Between 2018 and 2020 the Israeli spyware firm was
responsible for breaking into thousands of devices, according to
Tamir Gazneli, NSO's vice president of research and development.
During the trial, Gazneli said he disagreed with the idea that
his company sold "spyware," leading to an exchange with Perez in
which Gazneli insisted his firm's tools were used to gather
intelligence on targets but "not people."
"You don't consider the targets people, Mr. Gazneli?" Perez
asked him.
"That's not what I said," he responded. "What I said is that
the targets are intelligence targets of intelligence agencies."
AMERICAN TAXPAYERS SENT MILLIONS TO NSO'S COFFERS
The Central Intelligence Agency and the Federal Bureau of
Investigation collectively paid NSO $7.6 million, according to
court records. The agencies' past dealings with the Israeli
spyware company had previously been disclosed by The New York
Times, which said the CIA bankrolled Djibouti's purchase of NSO
spyware and the bureau bought it for testing, but the trial put
a price tag on the relationship.
NSO TARGETED WHATSAPP'S INFRASTRUCTURE DURING THE LAWSUIT
The lawsuit against NSO did not deter the spyware firm from
continuing to abuse WhatsApp's infrastructure, Meta's lawyers
said in a court document filed late last month.
"NSO repeatedly targeted Plaintiffs, Plaintiffs' servers,
and Plaintiffs' mobile client even after this litigation was
filed," the filing said.
The filing seeks a permanent injunction against NSO, which
it said "poses a significant threat of ongoing and prospective
harm" to Meta, its platform, and its users.