Oct 7 (Reuters) - Mortgage software provider Optimal
Blue and nearly 30 major lenders including Rocket Mortgage,
CrossCountry Mortgage and United Wholesale Mortgage have been
accused in a federal lawsuit of conspiring to inflate
residential mortgage fees for millions of U.S. homebuyers.
The proposed class action was filed on Monday in Nashville,
Tennessee, by homeowners in Tennessee, Minnesota, Delaware and
Rhode Island who claim the lenders used Optimal Blue's pricing
software to share non-public data on interest rates and fees,
allowing them to coordinate pricing in violation of federal
antitrust law.
The lawsuit claims the data-sharing scheme drove up mortgage
costs nationwide and "transformed the American dream of
homeownership into a financial nightmare."
Optimal Blue declined to comment, as did defendants United
Wholesale Mortgage, Bank of America ( BAC ) and Wells Fargo
. Defendants including Rocket Mortgage,
CrossCountry Mortgage and JPMorgan Chase ( JPM ) did not
immediately respond to requests for comment.
Attorney Robin van der Meulen, representing the homeowner
plaintiffs, in a statement said they looked forward to "holding
accountable unfair competitors and unfair competition, no matter
the mechanism."
The lawsuit describes Plano, Texas-based Optimal Blue as
"the dominant market intelligence and pricing software provider
in the U.S. mortgage industry."
Lenders pay for subscriptions to access its business
analytics tools, which allegedly have allowed them to monitor
competitors' pricing and adjust their own rates.
The lawsuit said Optimal Blue's tools include "daily,
non-public, real-time, loan-level data dissected at the local
level" and are used to price more than one-third of all
mortgages nationwide.
The proposed class includes borrowers nationwide who
obtained residential mortgages priced using Optimal Blue's tools
between October 2021 and the present.
The plaintiffs said they are seeking unspecified monetary
damages and a court order to stop the alleged price-fixing
scheme involving Optimal Blue and the mortgage lenders.
The case is Angel D. Mendez et al v. Optimal Blue LLC et al,
U.S. District Court for the Middle District of Tennessee, No.
3:25-cv-01140.
For plaintiffs: Robin van der Meulen, Carmen Medici and
Patrick McGahan of Scott + Scott Attorneys at Law, and Brian
Clark of Lockridge Grindal Nauen
For defendants: No appearances yet
Read more:
US judge guts consumer lawsuit against United Wholesale
Mortgage
Equifax must face antitrust lawsuit over verification
services
United Wholesale Mortgage defeats broker antitrust lawsuit