(Adds more quotes)
June 13 (Reuters) - Tesla shareholders look set
to approve a $56 billion pay package for its CEO Elon Musk by
wide margins, the billionaire said on social media on Wednesday.
Shareholder approval of the largest CEO package in U.S.
corporate history could allay investor concerns about Musk's
future at the company and give the electric-car maker ammunition
in its fight to reverse a court decision to void the pay
package.
Here are what some people are saying about it:
GARRETT NELSON, VICE PRESIDENT AND SENIOR EQUITY ANALYST AT
CFRA RESEARCH
"We consider this good news for TSLA investors and attribute
the success of the proposals to the overwhelming support of
TSLA's large retail investor base, who collectively own ~40% of
the shares, combined with a portion of its fragmented
institutional investor base where support was more divided."
"If approved later today, we think it would lift a major
near-term overhang on the stock, as investors send a strong
message of 'staying the course.' In our view, Musk has delivered
for shareholders over the past 5-6 years, meeting the lofty
thresholds of his entirely incentive-based compensation plan and
there's little reason to doubt this won't continue."
CHRISTOPHER TSAI, PRESIDENT AND CHIEF INVESTMENT OFFICER OF
TSAI CAPITAL, A NEW YORK-BASED INVESTMENT MANAGER
"People are invested in Tesla because they believe in Elon
and they believe in the company, and nothing has changed since
the previous vote. Pay the guy and let's move on, that's what
the shareholders have concluded."
DAN COATSWORTH, INVESTMENT ANALYST AT AJ BELL
"The prospect of Tesla investors approving a gargantuan pay
deal for Elon Musk is in itself perplexing given the $56 billion
amount, but for it to drive up the share price might also leave
some people scratching their heads. The logical explanation is
that it means Musk is no longer a flight risk, should the deal
be approved. Pay him well and he'll stay to oversee Tesla's
ongoing efforts to be crowned king of the electric vehicle
sector."
NEW YORK CITY COMPTROLLER BRAD LANDER, WHO OVERSEES CITY
WORKERS' RETIREMENT ASSETS
"Elon's tweet is more evidence of the failure of corporate
governance at Tesla - this is not how or when shareholder votes
are supposed to be made public."
"As long-term investors in Tesla, we expect genuine board
oversight and a CEO who is deeply committed to the company's
growth rather than other business ventures. We would like the
board to ensure that its approval is required for any attempts
to leverage Tesla's intellectual property or resources for his
other ventures so shareholders can trust that their interests
are aligned with the company's goals."
"Additionally, instead of continuing to try to defend it in
court, the board should hire a compensation consultant, and
renegotiate Musk's incentive plan so that it is appropriate and
not dilutive to shareholders."
JASON SCHLOETZER, A BUSINESS PROFESSOR AT GEORGETOWN
UNIVERSITY WITH EXPERTISE IN CORPORATE GOVERNANCE
The approval suggests shareholders "think he's the only
person with the best strategy to implement going forward. They
are brushing aside essentially key man risks, where Tesla has
become even more dependent on Musk going forward."
DAN IVES, ANALYST, WEDBUSH SECURITIES
"Based on all of our discussions over the past month large
shareholders at the end of the day knew that voting no would
risk Musk potentially eventually leaving as CEO and the risk far
overweighed the reward in voting no on this proposal despite
some obvious frustration with Musk."
ALEXANDER POTTER, SENIOR RESEARCH ANALYST, PIPER SANDLER &
CO
"This doesn't fully settle the matter; the compensation
package can still be deemed illegal. But a Delaware judge
previously struck down the package citing limited shareholder
disclosure, and given enhanced disclosures preceding this vote,
it's unclear why anyone would take issue with this
newly-ratified deal. We expect the stock to respond favorably to
this news, though the upside is perhaps unlikely to be as
violent as the downside would have been, had shareholders
rejected the deal."
SANDEEP RAO, SENIOR RESEARCHER AT LEVERAGE SHARES WHICH OWNS
TESLA SHARES
"This vindicates Musk and allays some investor concerns
around his waning interest in Tesla, but major institutional
shareholders who are opposing the pay package might seek value
elsewhere due to their concerns around the size of package,
especially given Tesla's recent disappointing performance and
rising competition."
GREG ABBOTT, TEXAS GOVERNOR
"Congrats Elon on getting the pay you were promised and on
your new incorporation in Texas."
"Welcome to a state that has neither a personal nor a
corporate income tax."
ADAM BADAWI, LAW PROFESSOR AT UC BERKELEY
"Even if the shareholders do approve the old package, it is
not clear that the Delaware court will allow that vote to be
effective."