(Adds quotes)
May 28 (Reuters) - U.S. trading moved to a shorter
settlement on Tuesday, which regulators hope will reduce risk
and improve efficiency in the world's largest financial market
but may temporarily lead to a rise in transaction failure for
investors.
To comply with a rule change the U.S. Securities and
Exchange Commission (SEC) adopted last February, investors in
U.S. equities, corporate and municipal bonds and other
securities must settle their transactions one business day after
the trade, instead of two, beginning Tuesday.
Here are some reactions:
JOHN OLEON, MANAGING DIRECTOR AT CLEAR STREET (a prime
brokerage)
"Tomorrow and the next day are the big days ... It comes
down to customer allocations and affirmations and that won't
really wash itself out for the next few days."
TED O'CONNOR, SENIOR VP, HEAD OF TREASURY SALES AT ARCESIUM
"I spoke to a number of my counterparts in the banking
world and in the asset management world and one of the things
that I have seen was there was an intentional effort to have a
little bit more cash on hand to address any fails that may come
out of this whole thing. I don't think it's a significant
increase, but it's certainly enough to be able to address a
normal settlement cycle that goes from two days to one.
"The mid-size, and the smaller managers are the ones
that we're going to be watching closely because they tend to be
more reliant on manual processes, on files coming from their
custody agents and their prime brokers in spreadsheets or in
PDFs ... and their processes are much more people-driven rather
than technology-driven."
JOE SALUZZI, PARTNER, CO-FOUNDER AND CO-HEAD OF EQUITY
TRADING, THEMIS TRADING, CHATHAM, NEW JERSEY.
"It's probably too soon to tell. I think everyone is
prepared for it. We've had things like this in the industry
before, so you prepare for it, and then wait and see basically.
I haven't seen anything new yet. We haven't had any problems.
Hopefully it goes well.
There will be some growing pains and a few hiccups I
would imagine... If there is something we'll all know pretty
quickly. Tomorrow morning we'll see if anything happened. It's
interesting because tomorrow it will be a settlement date for
two trading days - Friday and today's.
You could have potentially some issues with extended
settlements... But overall (T+1) is a good thing. When it comes
down to why they did it, it's lowering the risk. When there's
less time to settle, there's less risk."
NAWAN BUTT, HEAD OF CAPITAL MARKETS AT PURPOSE INVESTMENTS
IN TORONTO
"Every single asset manager out there is going to be
working very closely with their custodian today to make sure
everything can settle as quick as possible. But as far as
evaluating how the turnover has gone, that will require
aggregate data which is at earliest month-end, most likely
quarter-end."
"Throughout the day we will see if there are any issues.
I believe most managers have been very proactive in making sure
everything is booked properly ... There is a big value chain
involved in this process and now we have to make sure that the
t's are crossed and the i's are dotted and we'll be able to see
what fell through the cracks."
JEFF NAYLOR, CHIEF INDUSTRY OPERATIONS OFFICER AT THE INVESTMENT
COMPANY INSTITUTE:
"ICI has worked closely with our industry partners and
regulators to ensure a seamless transition to a T+1 settlement
cycle. To date, all T+1 implementation activities have been
completed according to plan. We are now operating in a T+1
settlement cycle and are monitoring transaction flow. Wednesday
is the last day market participants will settle T+2 transactions
coupled with the first day of finalizing T+1 trades, and we are
confident we will continue to see smooth execution.
"The US T+1 Command Center, co-led by ICI and SIFMA,
operated throughout the weekend to confirm readiness among major
market participants including DTCC, custodian banks, major
broker/dealers, buy-side participants, and trading and
infrastructure service providers to the industry. Additionally,
ICI and SIFMA updated regulators throughout the weekend
including the SEC, Federal Reserve Bank of NY, OCC, FINRA, and
Treasury."
SECURITIES INDUSTRY AND FINANCIAL MARKETS ASSOCIATION (published
on website)
"Over the weekend, SIFMA's T+1 Command Center was fully
engaged with the industry, discussing among the designated
participants such topics as conversion status information,
transparency into the activity of other participants, and issue
identification and socialization. That engagement will continue
throughout the week. The industry has taken steps to be ready
when the U.S. markets open today, which is the effective date of
the transition to T+1 settlement, and we look forward to
continued progress towards T+1 and helping investors and the
industry realize the benefits of this change."
NICK WOOD, HEAD OF EXECUTION AT MILLTECHFX AND MILLENNIUM
GLOBAL:
"The shift to T+1 is expected to reduce settlement risk but
comes with significant operational obstacles in the FX market.
For example, in Europe, it's estimated that $50bn-$70bn of daily
FX flows will no longer be able to settle via CLS, a key
component in managing settlement risk.
"Given that CLS has decided it won't be changing the current
cut-off times, after the US equity market closes there will be a
much tighter window of just two hours to process transactions,
execute the required FX trades to ensure dollars are available
and submit the trades to CLS.
"Those without a local US presence and who would have
historically executed the required FX trades the following
morning may have additional unintended costs. They could end up
extending execution and operational coverage into the late
evening which will potentially add to staffing costs. This may
also add to execution costs as they will be transacting during
illiquid hours. Alternative solutions such as pre-funding could
bring additional funding costs and utilizing their custodian due
to workflow simplicity may bring higher costs via fees plus
reduced transparency. Beyond this, the only other consideration
would be to accept settlement outside of CLS."
ERIC HUTTMAN, CEO OF MILLTECHFX:
"We expect most firms to make changes to staffing and
explore automating or even outsourcing, but with same-day
settlement looking increasingly likely, there is a significant
amount of work ahead for FX operations professionals to ensure
optimal workflows and a smooth transition."
BNY MELLON (published on website)
"We welcome this positive move to reduce settlement risk and
improve liquidity across the market. We will continue to closely
monitor the transition and keep this site updated."
ALEJANDRO FÉLIX, PRESIDENT OF THE MEXICAN ASSOCIATION OF STOCK
INSTITUTIONS' ADMINISTRATION COMMITTEE
"We live in a world that's ever more online. In an era where
everything is characterized by its immediacy, it no longer made
much sense to continue with last century's settlement
mechanisms."
"On the one hand, there is such a high correlation between
the American market and the Mexican market and, on the other,
there is an enormous appetite among the investing public for
stocks listed in the United States, which makes it very
important to have the same settlement cycle."