WASHINGTON, Nov 14 (Reuters) - A group of nine
Republican state attorneys general on Friday raised competition
concerns about Union Pacific's ( UNP ) plan to buy smaller rival
Norfolk Southern ( NSC ) in an $85 billion deal to create the
first U.S. coast-to-coast freight rail operator.
The officials, led by Tennessee Attorney General Jonathan
Skrmetti and Kansas Attorney General Kris Kobach, in a letter to
the Surface Transportation Board, which was seen by Reuters,
said they were concerned the deal "will result in undue market
concentration that stifles competition and therefore creates
higher prices, lower reliability, and less innovation at the
expense of America's manufacturers and, ultimately, America's
consumers."
The tie-up, if approved, could reshape the U.S. freight rail
industry and help streamline operations and eliminate
interchange delays in key hubs like Chicago.
The attorneys general of the states - which also include
Ohio, Florida, North Dakota, South Dakota, Mississippi, Montana
and Iowa - said the merger could result in high internal
shipping costs that could "kneecap American companies' ability
to compete with foreign manufacturers."
They also warned that the "downstream impact of the merger
poses significant risk not just for our industrial base but also
our agricultural producers. Ultimately, then, this merger could
compromise our national security."
Union Pacific ( UNP ) said in response on Friday that it looks
forward to submitting its application to the STB "to detail how
this combination is good for America, meets the threshold of
advancing public interest and enhances competition." The
railroad added it had won support from key unions and others to
"ensure rail is not left behind."
Norfolk Southern ( NSC ) did not immediately comment.
Earlier on Friday, the railroads said that more than 99% of
shareholders at both companies voted in favor of the deal. The
STB review could take about 12 to 18 months.
The railroad industry has struggled with volatile freight
volumes, rising labor and fuel costs, and growing pressure from
shippers over service reliability.
In September, President Donald Trump said the merger "sounds
good to me" after he met with Union Pacific ( UNP ) CEO Jim Vena to
discuss the deal for the biggest U.S. rail merger in decades.
Union Pacific ( UNP ) dominates freight rail operations in the
Western United States, while Norfolk Southern ( NSC ) is a leading
carrier in the East. Together, they form two of the four major
U.S. Class I railroads, alongside BNSF Railway and CSX Corp ( CSX )
.