ATLANTA, May 24 (Reuters) - U.S. trucking firms say a
government-mandated transition from diesel to electric big rigs
could end up costing them big money if customers are not willing
to pay a premium for zero-emissions shipping services.
Executives at several fleet owners told Reuters they have
had trouble persuading clients to pay more for use of their
electric trucks, with most prioritizing money over shining up
their climate credentials in a tough market.
"We're competing with companies that aren't willing to
change to zero-emissions," said Rudy Diaz, CEO of Hight
Logistics, a Los Angeles port trucking company with 20 electric
trucks.
Chevron Chief Procurement Officer Steve Freeman said his
team plans to use hydrogen trucks for its outsourced
zero-emission trucking services. But regardless of how those
cleaner trucks are powered, shippers won't pay a premium.
"That's the reality. Why would you?" Freeman said at the
Reuters Events Supply Chain conference in Atlanta.
State and federal regulators want to "green" U.S.
transportation because it is the largest single source of direct
greenhouse gas emissions. The sector accounts for 29% of U.S.
emissions, nearly a quarter of which came from medium- and
heavy-duty trucks, according to the Environmental Protection
Agency.
Progress so far has been slow.
Deployments of heavy-duty electric semi trucks rose from 100
in 2022 to 700 in 2023 - less than 1% of the total U.S. trucking
fleet, according to TRC Companies' 2024 State of Sustainable
Fleets report released on Monday.
The pace of future adoption, meanwhile, is unclear due to
truck manufacturing hiccups, California's delayed implementation
of electric fleet purchasing mandates, charging infrastructure
shortages and the Securities and Exchange Commission's decision
to drop a requirement for U.S.-listed companies to disclose
indirect emissions, according to the report.
Many U.S. trucking companies are also slow to buy EV rigs
because they added diesel-powered semi tractors during the early
pandemic's shipping boom and are now oversupplied, said Dan
Hearsch, Americas co-leader of the automotive and industrial
practice at consultancy AlixPartners.
"It isn't clear that electric semis and other delivery
trucks are very important to consumers. It's a 'nice-to-have,'
but not driving such decisions in any significant way," he said.
Electric semis can cost up to three times more than diesel
rigs. And while many companies have used government incentives
and grants to offset that extra expense, some of those subsidies
are scheduled to expire or phase out. California operators with
more than 50 trucks, for example, will lose access to state
purchase vouchers on January 1.
Katie Griley, president of family-run Griley Air Freight in
California, told Reuters she would like to buy more EVs for her
fleet but needs customers to support those investments with
long-term trucking contracts.
Her 90-truck fleet currently includes two electric Volvo
semis.
"It's a waiting game," she said.
Griley said she provides zero-emissions services to Kuehne +
Nagel without a premium because they move large
volumes. A second logistics firm does pay extra for green
trucking, but she did not disclose the fees.
Trucker Schneider National ( SNDR ) has 92 electric
eCascadia semis from Daimler Truck's Freightliner
division running cargo for PepsiCo's ( PEP ) Frito-Lay snack
division and Goodyear Tire.
Other zero-emissions customers include Dove soap brand owner
Unilever ( UL ), online retail giant Amazon.com ( AMZN ),
solar software seller Nextracker ( NXT ), scooter rental firm
Lime Technologies and Microsoft ( MSFT ), companies
and transport providers said at the Reuters Events conference.
Reuters was not immediately able to confirm whether these
companies pay premiums for zero-emissions services.
Brad Bayne, vice president of strategic initiatives at
Southern California's 4 Gen Logistics, said some of his
customers are paying a bit more for zero-emissions trucking from
its fleet of 64 electric semis. But convincing new customers to
pay extra is harder.
"With the current market conditions, I think the answer
would be a little mixed," Bayne said.