NEW YORK, Aug 16 (Reuters) - Starbucks ( SBUX ) has been
sued for a third time by a company that accused the coffee chain
of stealing its concept for coffee-flavored lipstick and lip
gloss.
Balmuccino, whose leaders have included a sister-in-law of
TV doctor Mehmet Oz, filed its complaint on Friday in Manhattan
federal court.
The filing followed a Seattle federal judge's July 2023
dismissal of an earlier version of the lawsuit on procedural
grounds, the second such dismissal.
Starbucks ( SBUX ), based in Seattle, had no immediate comment.
Balmuccino said it began developing coffee-flavored lip
balms in 2016 and pitched them at an October 2018 meeting in
Starbucks' ( SBUX ) New York office, where it provided prototypes and
other confidential information.
The Los Angeles-based company said Dr. Oz had brokered the
meeting, when he contacted Starbucks ( SBUX ) Chief Executive Howard
Schultz to suggest a possible joint venture.
Balmuccino said Starbucks ( SBUX ) "stole" its fully developed
concept for lip balms by launching its "S'mores Frappuccino Sip
Kit" in April 2019.
The kits included lipstick and gloss in four shades:
Campfire Spark, Chocolicious Bliss, Graham Glam and Marshmallow
Glow.
Balmuccino said Starbucks ( SBUX ) did not compensate it for selling
Sip Kits, and is seeking unspecified compensatory and punitive
damages.
It said its lawsuit is not too late because New York lets
some plaintiffs put statutes of limitation on hold when they sue
in the wrong forum and, "as here," a court finds it lacks
jurisdiction.
Balmuccino originally sued Starbucks ( SBUX ) in Los Angeles in
October 2019.
The case is Balmuccino LLC v. Starbucks Corp ( SBUX ), U.S. District
Court, Southern District of New York, No. 24-06214.