*
Committee publishes 569-page report on Credit Suisse
meltdown
*
Says 'years of mismanagement' caused crisis
*
Criticises lack of transparency at regulators
*
Report will be used to inform banking sector reforms
By Dave Graham and Ariane Luthi
BERN, Dec 20 (Reuters) - Swiss lawmakers called for
stricter oversight of the financial sector after investigating
the collapse of Credit Suisse, casting an unflattering light on
authorities while pinning the blame on the bank's implosion
primarily on its managers.
In a long-awaited 569-page report published on Friday,
lawmakers exposed Swiss bureaucracy that is unaccustomed to
scrutiny, rebuking regulators for being secretive and
mistrustful, and for responding at times haphazardly to the
crisis that felled the bank in March 2023.
Arch rival UBS stepped in to buy Credit Suisse for
a fraction of its value in a government-orchestrated rescue.
In June 2023, parliament took the unusual step of forming a
committee to probe the official response to the Credit Suisse
meltdown. Interviews with those involved were held privately.
The government has said it will use the findings to inform
its plans for reform of the banking sector.
"The (committee) considers Credit Suisse's years of
mismanagement to be the cause of the crisis," say the opening
lines of a statement accompanying its report, translated from
German.
The committee, known as PUK, chronicled in detail the
chaotic final days of the bank, and criticized a lack of
transparency during months of crisis meetings between finance
ministry officials, the central bank, and the market regulator
FINMA, urging them to keep written records in future.
"However, the PUK does not see any causal misconduct on the
part of the authorities for the Credit Suisse crisis and finds
that they prevented a global financial crisis," it wrote.
The unravelling of 167-year-old Credit Suisse, a pillar of
the financial establishment and the country's second-biggest
lender, left Switzerland with just one major international bank,
which now holds a balance sheet bigger than the entire economy.
The government in April sketched out 'too-big-to-fail' plans
to ensure UBS does not go the same way as Credit Suisse,
centring chiefly on making the bank hold more capital. But it
vowed not to give more specifics until after the PUK report.
The committee's conclusions did not offer prescriptive
advice on how the banking sector should be reformed, but the
broad sweep of the 30 recommendations and requests directed at
the government cleaved closely to those April proposals.
It pressed the government to strengthen FINMA and ensure
"appropriate consideration" be given to the foreign units of
systemically relevant banks such as UBS, which authorities have
said could need bigger capital buffers to weather crises.
The PUK report also argued that financial incentives in the
sector should not be skewed after noting that bonuses paid out
to Credit Suisse's management between 2010 and 2022 exceeded the
bank's 34 billion Swiss francs ($37.9 billion) in losses during
that period.
The committee criticized FINMA for granting Credit Suisse
relief in how much capital the lender needed to hold in the
years before its undoing and urged the government to limit such
concessions in future.
UBS has argued that systemically important banks already
have enough capital and that excessive demands could hurt
business and undermine Switzerland's attractiveness to
investors.
NON-MEETINGS
Officials were discussing the potential demise of Credit
Suisse for months, but the report found that many of their
discussions were ad hoc and lacking in transparency.
In particular, the inquiry raised questions about how former
Finance Minister Ueli Maurer shared information about the bank
with his successor Karin Keller-Sutter, who took office in 2023.
Maurer, who with former Swiss National Bank Chairman Thomas
Jordan initiated informal "non-meetings" that created a
"parallel format" to crisis-management authorities, told
lawmakers he was concerned about damaging leaks, the PUK said.
Looking to reassure markets, Maurer publicly backed Credit
Suisse in December 2022, telling Swiss television: "You just
have to leave them alone for a year or two."
But as he prepared to hand over to Keller-Sutter, he did not
do enough to warn her, telling her around Christmas time that
the bank was in a stable condition, the report said.
"The PUK reaches the conclusion that the departmental
handover regarding the Credit Suisse dossier did not proceed
ideally. A dossier handover did not actually take place."
Though the report said Keller-Sutter injected more urgency
into proceedings, she was criticised for failing to keep the
cabinet apprised fast enough about findings on how the crisis
might play out.
Such was the hermetic manner in which top officials handled
the crisis, the report said, that the full cabinet was only
informed about events in late 2022 heralding Credit Suisse's
ultimate demise during its final days in March 2023.
($1 = 0.8980 Swiss francs)