April 15 (Reuters) - VF Corp's ( VFC ) boot maker
Timberland cannot receive a federal trademark covering certain
elements of its famous boot design, a U.S. appeals court said on
Monday.
The 4th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals upheld the U.S. Patent
and Trademark Office's decision that features of the boots
including its sole color, eyelets and stitching were not
distinctive enough to identify the boots as Timberland products.
Representatives for Timberland did not immediately respond
to requests for comment on the decision. A spokesperson for the
USPTO declined to comment.
Timberland applied for a federal trademark covering the
features in 2015. The USPTO rejected the application in a
decision that was later upheld by an office tribunal and a
Virginia federal court.
The 4th Circuit agreed with the office on Monday and said
Timberland failed to show that the design features encourage
customers to buy its boots "because, to the public, those
features make the boot a Timberland product."
The appeals court noted that Timberland's trademark
application did not include "more conspicuous" aspects of its
boots that may identify them more clearly as Timberland
products, including its tree logo, lug soles and best-selling
"wheat-yellow" color.
"Some consumers might recognize the whole boot, unclaimed
features and all, as a Timberland," U.S. Circuit Judge Marvin
Quattlebaum wrote for a three-judge panel. "But TBL did not
undertake to register the entire boot."
The case is TBL Licensing LLC v. Vidal, 4th U.S. Circuit
Court of Appeals, No. 23-1150.
For Timberland: Elizabeth Ferrill of Finnegan Henderson
Farabow Garrett & Dunner
For the USPTO: Christina Hieber of the USPTO
(Reporting by Blake Brittain in Washington)