*
Merger in question is HP Enterprise deal with Juniper
Networks
*
US Senators ask judge for hearing on merger and public
interest
*
Rift seen between robust antitrust enforcement and
dealmakers
By Jody Godoy and Sarah N. Lynch
July 29 (Reuters) - Two officials at the U.S. Department
of Justice's antitrust division have been fired for
insubordination, a source familiar with the decision said on
Tuesday, as controversy builds over how the DOJ reached a recent
settlement greenlighting Hewlett Packard Enterprise's ( HPE )
$14 billion acquisition of Juniper Networks.
The source said the firings removed two top deputies of
Assistant Attorney General Gail Slater, a former JD Vance
advisor who leads the antitrust division. The move exposed a
power struggle within President Donald Trump's administration
between proponents of robust antitrust enforcement and
dealmakers seeking to leverage influence.
Roger Alford, a former official during the first Trump
administration who was Slater's top deputy, and Bill Rinner, a
former counsel at hedge fund Apollo Global Management who was in
charge of merger enforcement, were no longer listed among
antitrust leadership on a Justice Department website on Tuesday.
Alford and Rinner did not immediately respond to requests
for comment.
Shortly after Trump took office in January, the Justice
Department sued to block the deal, alleging it would harm
competition in the market for wireless networking solutions used
by large enterprises. HP Enterprise started negotiating the deal
with the DOJ on March 25, around two weeks after Slater was
sworn in, according to court papers.
Ahead of a scheduled trial, the DOJ agreed to drop its
claims in exchange for HP Enterprise agreeing to license some of
Juniper's AI technology to competitors and sell off a unit that
caters to small and mid-sized businesses.
Slater and several Justice officials, including Rinner and
Alford, signed the settlement rather than staff attorneys on the
case, a move that sources familiar with merger protocol called
unusual.
Chad Mizelle, Attorney General Pam Bondi's chief of staff,
was one of the officials who signed the deal.
Mizelle had directed the antitrust division to settle the
case, according to a person briefed on the matter. After Slater
pushed back, Mizelle sought to fire Slater's deputies in
retaliation, the person said.
Four Democratic senators led by Elizabeth Warren of
Massachusetts, on Tuesday called on the federal judge overseeing
the merger case to hold a hearing on whether the settlement is
in the public interest.
U.S. law seeks to guard against backdoor merger clearance of
merger deals by requiring merging companies to disclose
communications with "any officer or employee of the United
States concerning or relevant to" a settlement proposal.
The senators want U.S. District Judge Casey Pitts in San
Jose, California, to probe whether companies hired consultants
to lobby the White House in support of the deal and failed to
disclose them.
"If this or any other transaction is approved based on
political favors rather than on the merits, the public will
surely bear the cost," the senators wrote.