May 20 (Reuters) - The estate of Henrietta Lacks can
move forward with a lawsuit against biopharmaceutical company
Ultragenyx over the use of cells taken from Lacks' body
in the 1950s, a Maryland federal court said on Monday.
U.S. District Judge Deborah Boardman rejected Ultragenyx's
motion to dismiss the case, ruling that the estate had plausibly
claimed that Ultragenyx wrongly profited from its research using
the "immortal" HeLa cell line.
An attorney for Ultragenyx declined to comment.
The HeLa cells were cut from Lacks' cervix without her
knowledge during a cancer-treatment procedure at a Baltimore
hospital in 1951. The cell line was the first to survive and
reproduce indefinitely in lab conditions and has been used in a
wide range of medical research worldwide.
"We applaud Judge Boardman's historic ruling, which allows
our unjust enrichment claims to proceed and acknowledges the
deep injustices that Henrietta Lacks and her family have
endured," the estate's attorneys Christopher Seeger and
Christopher Ayers of Seeger Weiss said in a statement.
The estate previously sued Thermo Fisher Scientific ( TMO ) for its
alleged misuse of the HeLa line in a case that settled last
year.
The Lacks estate sued Novato, California-based Ultragenyx,
which develops treatments for rare genetic diseases, days after
the Thermo Fisher settlement. The estate accused the company of
using HeLa cells "like a dairy farm treats cows" to mass-produce
materials for gene therapy.
"HeLa cells' impact on medical research is unassailable,"
Ultragenyx told the court in its motion to dismiss the case.
"But Plaintiff has sued the wrong defendant, using an invalid
legal theory, in pursuit of 'huge profits' that do not exist."
Boardman said in denying Ultragenyx's motion that the
estate's case was strong enough to continue.
"Ultragenyx asks this Court to find that its acquisition and
use of HeLa cells is too remote from the seizure of cells from
Henrietta Lacks for Lacks to state a claim for unjust
enrichment," Boardman said. "That is not the law."
The case is Lacks v. Ultragenyx Pharmaceutical Inc ( RARE ), U.S.
District Court for the District of Maryland, No. 1:23-cv-02171.
For Lacks: Ben Crump of Ben Crump Law; Christopher Seeger,
Christopher Ayers and Jeffrey Grand of Seeger Weiss; and Kim
Parker of the Law Offices of Kim Parker
For Ultragenyx: Nadira Clarke and Andrew George of Baker
Botts; and Tonya Cronin of Baker Donelson
Read more:
Henrietta Lacks' family sues Ultragenyx over use of HeLa
cell line
Thermo Fisher settles Henrietta Lacks lawsuit over 'HeLa'
cell line
(Reporting by Blake Brittain in Washington)