*
Court decision will be appealed to the Supreme Court -
TikTok
CEO
*
DOJ says TikTok is a threat to national security and
should be
sold
*
Trump has vowed to prevent TikTok from being barred
(Adds TikTok CEO comment, Chinese embassy statement, closing
share prices, Google declining comment)
By David Shepardson and Mike Scarcella
WASHINGTON, Dec 6 (Reuters) - A U.S. federal appeals
court on Friday upheld a law requiring Chinese-based ByteDance
to divest its popular short video app TikTok in the United
States by early next year or face a ban.
The decision is a major win for the Justice Department and
opponents of the Chinese-owned app and a devastating blow to
TikTok parent ByteDance. It significantly raises the prospects
of an unprecedented ban in just six weeks on a social media app
used by 170 million Americans.
TikTok plans to appeal the decision to the Supreme Court.
In detailing their support of the law, the appeals court
noted it was the result of Republicans and Democrats working
together, as well as two presidents, as "part of a broader
effort to counter a well-substantiated national security threat
posed by the PRC (People's Republic of China)."
The Justice Department says under Chinese ownership, TikTok
poses a threat because of its access to vast personal data of
Americans, asserting China can covertly manipulate information
that Americans consume via TikTok.
Attorney General Merrick Garland called the decision "an
important step in blocking the Chinese government from
weaponizing TikTok."
But the Chinese Embassy in Washington called the law "a
blatant act of commercial robbery" and warned the United States
"must handle this case in a prudent manner to avoid harming the
mutual trust between the two countries and the development of
bilateral relations."
The ruling comes amid growing trade tensions between the
world's two biggest economies after the administration of
President Joe Biden placed new restrictions on China's chip
industry and Beijing responded by imposing an outright ban on
exports of gallium, germanium and antimony to the United States.
U.S. appeals court Judges Sri Srinivasan, Neomi Rao and
Douglas Ginsburg rejected legal challenges brought by TikTok and
users against the law, which gives ByteDance until Jan. 19 to
sell or divest TikTok's U.S. assets or face a ban.
FREE SPEECH
"While today's news is disappointing, rest assured we will
continue the fight to protect free speech on our platform,"
TikTok CEO Shou Zi Chew said in an email to staff seen by
Reuters.
Free speech advocates quickly criticized the ruling. The
American Civil Liberties Union said, "Banning TikTok blatantly
violates the First Amendment rights of millions of Americans who
use this app to express themselves and communicate with people
around the world."
In its analysis, the court said China, through its
relationship with TikTok parent ByteDance, threatened to distort
U.S. speech through TikTok and "manipulate public discourse."
China's "ability to do so is at odds with free speech
fundamentals. Indeed, the First Amendment precludes a domestic
government from exercising comparable control over a social
media company in the United States."
The decision -- unless the Supreme Court reverses it -- puts
TikTok's fate in the hands of first President Biden on whether
to grant a 90-day extension of the Jan. 19 deadline to force a
sale and then President-elect Donald Trump, who takes office on
Jan. 20. But it's not clear whether ByteDance could meet the
heavy burden to show it had made significant progress toward a
divestiture needed to trigger the extension -- or if the Chinese
government would approve any sale.
Trump, who unsuccessfully tried to ban TikTok during his
first term in 2020, said before the November presidential
election he would not allow the TikTok ban.
Friday's decision upholds the law giving the U.S. government
sweeping powers to ban other foreign-owned apps that could raise
concerns about collection of Americans' data -- and could open
the door to a future crackdown on many other foreign owned apps.
In 2020, Trump also tried to ban Tencent-owned WeChat, but was
blocked by the courts.
TIKTOK BAN LOOMS
If banned, TikTok advertisers would seek new social media
venues to buy ads. As a result, shares of Meta Platforms ( META )
, which competes against TikTok in online ads, hit an
intraday record high following the ruling and closed up 2.4%.
Google parent Alphabet, whose YouTube video platform
also competes with TikTok, closed up 1.25%.
The court opinion - which was written by Ginsburg, an
appointee of President Ronald Reagan, and joined by Rao, who was
named to the bench by Trump, and Srinivasan, an appointee of
President Barack Obama - acknowledged its decision would lead to
TikTok's ban on Jan. 19 without an extension from Biden.
ByteDance, backed by Sequoia Capital, Susquehanna
International Group, KKR & Co ( KKR ), and General Atlantic,
among others, was valued at $268 billion in December 2023 when
it offered to buy back around $5 billion worth of shares from
investors, Reuters reported then.
The law prohibits app stores like Apple ( AAPL ) and
Alphabet's Google from offering TikTok and bars
internet hosting services from supporting TikTok unless
ByteDance divests TikTok by the deadline.
Google declined comment while Apple ( AAPL ) did not respond to a
request for comment.
In a concurring opinion, Srinivasan acknowledged the
decision will have major impacts, noting "170 million Americans
use TikTok to create and view all sorts of free expression and
engage with one another and the world. And yet, in part
precisely because of the platform's expansive reach, Congress
and multiple Presidents determined that divesting it from
(China's) control is essential to protect our national
security."