* CBP collected $166 billion in illegal tariffs from
330,000 importers
* CBP is preparing a refund system that will not require
importers to sue
* Judge no longer demands "immediate compliance" with
earlier order
By Tom Hals
March 6 (Reuters) - The U.S. customs agency is readying
a system within 45 days to process refunds on U.S. President
Donald Trump's tariffs that were struck down as illegal, a
customs official said in a court filing on Friday.
The declaration by Customs and Border Protection official
Brandon Lord came just before government lawyers met with a
federal trade judge to try to hammer out a broad settlement
process, as Reuters reported exclusively on Friday, for
returning $166 billion in tariff payments to around 330,000
importers.
Last month, the U.S. Supreme Courtstruck down as
unconstitutional the tariffs that were a central part of Trump's
economic policy. The court did not say how the collected tariffs
should be refunded, leaving small importers worried the process
would be expensive and time-consuming.
"This new process will require minimal submission from
importers," Lord said in his declaration, filed with the U.S.
Court of International Trade as government lawyers began meeting
with Judge Richard Eaton from the court.
Eaton called the meeting to discuss how the government will
carry out his sweeping order issued on Wednesday directing the
CBP to begin refunding tariffs to potentially hundreds of
thousands of importers using the agency's existing internal
process.
On Friday, after concluding the meeting with the government
lawyers, he said in a court filing he was amending that order to
no longer require "immediate compliance," and appeared to be
giving CBP time to carry out the new system. Eaton said he
changed his order after considering the "declaration of Brandon
Lord."
Eaton said in his Wednesday order that he had been appointed
by the trade court to hear the roughly 2,000 lawsuits filed by
importers including FedEx ( FDX ) and L'Oreal seeking
refunds. Trade lawyers said those lawsuits were the tip of the
iceberg, and thousands more were prepared to sue if the
government failed to develop a system for automatic refunds.
Affiliates of Nintendo ( NTDOF ) and CVS became the
latest large companies to sue for refunds on Friday.
SINGLE PAYMENT FOR IMPORTERS
Lord said in the court filing that the customs agency
expected importers to file a declaration with the CBP's computer
system known as ACE detailing tariff payments, which would then
be validated before refunds are processed with interest. The
importers would not have to sue.
Each importer would receive a single payment from the
Treasury Department, regardless of how many separate entries of
goods the importer had made.
Lord did not estimate how long it would take to process the
refunds, but said the CBP would not be able to comply with
Eaton's order from Wednesday. Eaton contemplated refunds would
be automatically returned to importers through the existing
system without documentation or input from the importer.
"Its existing administrative procedures and technology are
not well-suited to a task of this scale and will require manual
work that will prevent personnel from fully carrying out the
agency's trade enforcement mission," Lord said in explaining why
the agency could not use its existing system.
He said importers had paid an estimated $166 billion in
tariffs on more than 53 million shipments. Eaton's order would
have required the agency to manually review paperwork on every
shipment, a process Lord said would require more than 4 million
hours of labor.
'PRACTICAL PROPOSAL'
The U.S. Chamber of Commerce, the largest U.S. business lobbying
group, applauded the CBP's 45-day plan as "a constructive and
practical proposal" to administer refunds efficiently.
"Most importantly, this proposal would spare the hundreds
of thousands of small businesses who are owed refunds from
having to litigate to obtain them," the Chamber's chief policy
officer, Neil Bradley, said in a statement that also encouraged
further refinements.
However, Lord's declaration also indicated that few
importers had signed up for the CBP's electronic system for
refunds. Out of more than 330,000 importers who paid the illegal
duties, only 21,423 signed up for the electronic refund system
that went into place on February 6, according to Lord.
Eaton is overseeing a refund lawsuit by Atmus Filtration
Inc, which the judge is using as a vehicle to order CBP to issue
the refunds for all importers.