NEW YORK / BOSTON, Dec 13 (Reuters) - Top U.S. asset
managers worried that signing up to an industry climate
initiative could make them appear to be working too closely
together and draw regulatory scrutiny, according to a report
released Friday by a Republican-led U.S. Congressional
Committee.
The report is the latest released by the panel's Republican
majority as part of a probe they say has shown fund firms and
activists are part of a "climate cartel" that colludes through
shareholder organizations pressing to cut emissions. The
committee's Democrats have dismissed those allegations.
Top fund firms have denied wrongdoing, but material cited in
the report shows they had always been concerned about appearing
too cozy with shareholder groups engaged in climate activism.
BlackRock's ( BLK ) view in 2019 was that "We don't do collective
action/engagements. Too risky," according to the report, citing
an e-mailed summary of a meeting that unidentified BlackRock ( BLK )
executives held with Ceres, a Boston-based environmental
advocacy group, obtained by the committee.
Likewise State Street also raised concerns around
2020 about "collusion" if it joined a Ceres-backed effort to
press companies to cut emissions known as the Climate Action
100+, according to the report. The firm worried about raising
the "perception of engaging or voting as a block," the report
states.
BlackRock ( BLK ) declined to comment. State Street and Ceres did
not immediately comment. Both wound up joining the group known
as the CA100+, then stepped back earlier this year citing
independence concerns.
Republican officials, many of them from oil and gas
producing states, have objected to investors coordinating to
pressure corporate management on climate issues at the expense
of corporate growth and returns.
Last month Republican attorneys general from 11 states sued
BlackRock ( BLK ), State Street and Vanguard, saying their climate
activism reduced coal production and boosted energy prices. The
firms collectively manage $26 trillion. BlackRock ( BLK ) and State
Street have denied wrongdoing, while Vanguard has declined to
comment on the matter.
U.S. president-elect Donald Trump campaigned against
President Joe Biden's moves to fight climate change and promised
to boost U.S. oil and gas production. In theory Trump's
administration could follow up on the congressional committee's
findings. A spokesperson for the committee declined to comment
on what if any talks it may have had with current or future
administrations.