*
Judge finds sanctions would not be meaningful
*
Musk missed court-ordered testimony for SpaceX launch
*
SEC probing Musk's $44 billion Twitter takeover
(Adds details from decision, SEC and Musk arguments,
background, case citation, byline)
By Jonathan Stempel
Nov 22 (Reuters) -
A federal judge on Friday rejected the U.S. Securities and
Exchange Commission's request to sanction Elon Musk after he
failed to appear for court-ordered testimony for the regulator's
probe into his $44 billion takeover of Twitter.
U.S. District Judge Jacqueline Scott Corley in San Francisco
said sanctions over Musk's Sept. 10 absence were unnecessary,
after the world's richest person testified on Oct. 3 and agreed
to pay the SEC's $2,923 of travel costs.
"Because the present circumstances forestall any
occasion for meaningful relief that the court could grant, the
SEC's request is moot," Corley wrote.
The SEC had sought a declaration that Musk violated a
May 31 court order to provide testimony.
It said having only to repay travel costs would not
deter many other people from ignoring court orders, "much less
someone of Musk's extraordinary means."
Musk said he complied with the order by testifying on
Oct. 3. He is worth $321.7 billion according to Forbes magazine.
The SEC did not immediately respond to a request for
comment after business hours. Lawyers for Musk did not
immediately respond to similar requests.
Musk, whose businesses include electric car maker Tesla
and rocket company SpaceX and who is the world's
richest person, went to Florida's Cape Canaveral on Sept. 10 to
oversee the launch of SpaceX's Polaris Dawn mission.
The SEC is
investigating
whether Musk violated securities laws in early 2022 by
waiting at least 10 days too long to disclose he had begun
accumulating Twitter stock.
Critics and some investors have said this let him buy
shares cheaply before he eventually disclosed a 9.2% Twitter
stake, and shortly thereafter offered to buy the whole company.
In July, Musk said he misunderstood SEC disclosure rules
and that "all indications" suggested he made a "mistake."
The SEC also sued Musk in 2018 over his Twitter posts
about taking Tesla private. He settled that lawsuit by paying a
$20 million fine, agreeing to let Tesla lawyers review some
posts in advance and stepping down as Tesla's chairman.
The case is SEC v Musk, U.S. District Court, Northern
District of California, No. 23-mc-80253.