financetom
Business
financetom
/
Business
/
US Supreme Court rules against Warner Music in copyright damages case
News World Market Environment Technology Personal Finance Politics Retail Business Economy Cryptocurrency Forex Stocks Market Commodities
US Supreme Court rules against Warner Music in copyright damages case
May 9, 2024 8:21 AM

WASHINGTON (Reuters) -The U.S. Supreme Court on Thursday ruled in favor of a Miami music producer in a legal fight with Warner Music ( WMG ) over a song by rapper Flo Rida, finding that there is no time limit for recovering monetary damages in copyright cases that have been filed before the expiration of a statue of limitations.

The 6-3 ruling, authored by liberal Justice Elena Kagan, affirmed a lower court's decision that favored producer Sherman Nealy, who sued a Warner subsidiary and others in Florida federal court in 2018.

Nealy has said that his label Music Specialist owns rights to the electronic dance song "Jam the Box" by Tony Butler, also known as Pretty Tony. Warner artist Flo Rida, whose given name is Tramar Dillard, incorporated elements of "Jam the Box" into his 2008 song "In the Ayer."

Nealy sued music publishing company Warner Chappell and others, arguing that they took an invalid license to "Jam the Box" from Butler, his former business partner, while Nealy was incarcerated for cocaine distribution. The producer requested damages for alleged copyright infringement dating back to 2008.

A federal judge decided that Nealy could recover damages only for infringement that happened during the three years before he filed the lawsuit, based on the U.S. statute of limitations for bringing a copyright-infringement case after discovering a claim. The Atlanta-based 11th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals reversed that decision and said there was "no bar to damages in a timely action."

The Supreme Court upheld the 11th Circuit's ruling on Thursday.

"The Copyright Act entitles a copyright owner to recover damages for any timely claim," Kagan wrote, referring to the 1976 federal law at issue in the case.

"If Nealy's claims are thus timely, he may obtain damages for them," Kagan added.

Warner declined comment. A lawyer for Nealy did not immediately respond to a request for comment.

During Supreme Court arguments in February, some of the justices indicated they could not decide the case before reconsidering the issue of statute of limitations in a separate dispute before them. The justices are currently deliberating whether to take up the "discovery rule" in a copyright dispute between Hearst Newspapers and photographer Antonio Martinelli.

"What concerns me is that we are being asked to decide a question that may be eliminated based on a subsequent decision" on whether the "discovery rule" applies, conservative Justice Samuel Alito said during the arguments.

Conservative Justice Neil Gorsuch echoed Alito's statements in a dissenting opinion on Thursday that was joined by Alito and Justice Clarence Thomas.

Comments
Welcome to financetom comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
Related Articles >
Booking Holdings Q4 Earnings: Revenue Beat, EPS Beat, Dividend Increase, Shares Move Higher
Booking Holdings Q4 Earnings: Revenue Beat, EPS Beat, Dividend Increase, Shares Move Higher
Feb 20, 2025
Booking Holdings Inc ( BKNG ) reported fourth-quarter financial results after the market close on Thursday. Here’s a rundown of the report. Q4 Earnings: Booking Holdings ( BKNG ) reported fourth-quarter revenue of $5.47 billion, beating analyst estimates of $5.18 billion. The online travel agency company reported fourth-quarter adjusted earnings of $41.55 per share, beating analyst estimates of $35.89 per...
Newmont Q4 Earnings, Revenue Rise
Newmont Q4 Earnings, Revenue Rise
Feb 20, 2025
04:19 PM EST, 02/20/2025 (MT Newswires) -- Newmont ( NEM ) reported Q4 adjusted diluted earnings Thursday of $1.40 per share, up from $0.46 a year earlier. Analysts polled by FactSet expected $1.08. Revenue in the three months ended Dec. 31 rose to $5.65 billion from $3.96 billion a year earlier. Analysts surveyed by FactSet expected $5.15 billion. ...
Sprouts Farmers Market Q4 Adjusted Earnings, Sales Rise; 2025 Outlook Issued
Sprouts Farmers Market Q4 Adjusted Earnings, Sales Rise; 2025 Outlook Issued
Feb 20, 2025
04:20 PM EST, 02/20/2025 (MT Newswires) -- Sprouts Farmers Market ( SFM ) reported Q4 adjusted earnings late Thursday of $0.79 per diluted share, up from $0.49 a year earlier. Analysts polled by FactSet expected $0.73. Net sales in the quarter ended Dec. 29 were $2.0 billion, up from $1.70 billion a year earlier. Analysts surveyed by FactSet expected $1.96...
FTAI Aviation Shares Surge After Resolving Short Seller Allegations
FTAI Aviation Shares Surge After Resolving Short Seller Allegations
Feb 20, 2025
FTAI Aviation Ltd. ( FTAI ) shares are trading higher Thursday following a major announcement that addressed recent short-seller reports. What To Know: The company revealed that its Audit Committee, with the help of independent legal and forensic accounting advisors, had reviewed the allegations made in January. After conducting a review, FTAI confirmed that the claims were unfounded and without...
Copyright 2023-2026 - www.financetom.com All Rights Reserved