May 27 (Reuters) - The U.S. Supreme Court declined on
Tuesday to hear a Native American group's bid based on religious
rights to block Rio Tinto and BHP from gaining
control of Arizona land needed to build one of the world's
largest copper mines - a project situated on land long used for
Apache sacred rituals.
The justices turned away an appeal by Apache Stronghold, an
advocacy group comprised of Arizona's San Carlos Apache tribe
and conservationists, of a lower court's ruling that allowed the
federal government to swap acreage with the mining companies for
their Resolution Copper project.
A federal judge in Arizona on May 8 temporarily blocked
Republican President Donald Trump's administration from moving
forward with the land transfer pending the outcome of the appeal
to the Supreme Court.
The project is 55% owned by British-Australian mining
company Rio Tinto and 45% by Australian mining company BHP. Rio
Tinto is the project's operator. Both companies have spent more
than $2 billion on the project without yet producing any copper.
The plaintiffs sued in 2021 in Arizona federal court to
block the project, saying it violated constitutional and
statutory protections for religious rights. They argued that the
project, because it was destroy a religiously important site,
would violate the U.S. Constitution's First Amendment
protections for the free exercise of religion, as well as a
1993 federal law called the Religious Freedom Restoration Act.
The destruction of the sacred site also would violate a 1852
treaty promising that the U.S. government would protect the land
and "secure the permanent prosperity and happiness" of the
Native American tribe, the plaintiffs said.
The land swap was approved as part of a defense spending
bill signed in 2014 by Democratic President Barack Obama,
allowing the companies to exchange acreage they own for a plot
of federally owned land about 70 miles (113 km) east of Phoenix
known as Oak Flat.
The swap was conditioned on an environmental impact
statement for the mine being published by federal regulators,
which occurred in January 2021 in the waning days of Trump's
first term in office.
The site sits atop a reserve of more than 40 billion pounds
(18.1 million metric tons) of copper, a crucial component of
electric vehicles and nearly every electronic device.
The land, known as Chi'chil Biłdagoteel in the Apache
language, has long been a place where Western Apaches have
conduct sacred rituals, according to the Apache group's
historian and its lawyers at the Becket Fund for Religious
Liberty.
If the mine is built, it would create a crater 2 miles (3
km) wide and 1,000 feet (304 m) deep that would destroy that
worship site.
After a federal judge declined to halt the land transfer in
2021, Apache Stronghold filed an emergency appeal. Shortly
before former Democratic President Joe Biden's administration
was to respond to that appeal, it announced in March 2021 that
it was withdrawing the environmental impact statement, a move
that froze the land transfer.
The San Francisco-based 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in
two different rulings declined to block the transfer, mostly
recently when a panel of 11 judges ruled 6-5 against the
plaintiffs in March 2024. The panel split along ideological
lines, with six judges appointed by Republican presidents in the
majority.
Judges in the majority throughout the appeals process said
that while they were they were sensitive to the religious
concerns, they felt compelled to rule narrowly on the question
of whether the U.S. government can do what it wants with its own
land.
After Trump returned to office, the U.S. Forest Service on
April 17 said it would republish within 60 days an environmental
report needed for the Resolution Copper project land swap to
occur. A federal judge on May 9 blocked it from doing so pending
the outcome of the Supreme Court appeal.