*
Lower court let suit led by Swedish firm proceed
*
Nvidia ( NVDA ) accused of concealing the impact of cryptomining
By John Kruzel
WASHINGTON, Dec 11 (Reuters) - The U.S. Supreme Court
sidestepped on Wednesday a decision on whether to allow
shareholders to proceed with a securities fraud lawsuit accusing
artificial intelligence chipmaker Nvidia ( NVDA ) of misleading
investors about how much of its sales depended on the volatile
cryptocurrency market.
The justices, who heard arguments on Nov. 13 after earlier
deciding to take up the case, dismissed Nvidia's ( NVDA ) appeal of a
lower court's ruling that allowed a 2018 class action -
litigation led by the Stockholm, Sweden-based investment
management firm E. Ohman J:or Fonder AB - to move forward.
The Supreme Court opted not resolve the underlying legal
dispute, determining that the case should not have been granted.
Its action leaves the lower court's decision in place.
The court's dismissal came in a one-line order that provided
no explanation.
At issue was whether the plaintiffs cleared the heightened
legal bar for bringing private securities fraud suits set under
a 1995 federal law called the Private Securities Litigation
Reform Act that aimed to screen out frivolous litigation.
The plaintiffs accused Nvidia ( NVDA ) and its CEO Jensen Huang of
violating a 1934 federal law called the Securities Exchange Act
by making statements in 2017 and 2018 that falsely downplayed
how much of Nvidia's ( NVDA ) revenue growth came from crypto-related
purchases.
Beginning in 2017, as the price of certain cryptocurrencies
rose, Nvidia's ( NVDA ) chips became increasingly popular for
cryptomining, a process that involves performing complex math
equations in order to secure cryptocurrencies such as bitcoin
and ether.
By late 2018, amid a decline in crypto profitability,
Nvidia's ( NVDA ) revenue fell short of its projections, leading its
stock price to fall in early November of that year.
The plaintiffs accused Nvidia ( NVDA ) and its top officials of
concealing the impact of cryptomining on its business. The suit
seeks unspecified monetary damages in part to recoup the lost
value of the Nvidia ( NVDA ) stock held by the investors.
Nvidia ( NVDA ) in 2022 agreed to pay $5.5 million to U.S.
authorities to settle charges that it did not properly disclose
the impact of cryptomining on its gaming business, but without
admitting or denying the findings of federal regulators.
A federal judge dismissed the lawsuit but the San
Francisco-based 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals subsequently
revived it. The 9th Circuit found that the plaintiffs had
adequately alleged that Huang made "false or misleading
statements and did so knowingly or recklessly," allowing their
case to proceed.
Nvidia ( NVDA ) argued to the Supreme Court that the plaintiffs had
failed to adequately show that the disputed corporate statements
were false, or the company had intentionally or recklessly
misled investors, as required by law.
The plaintiffs countered that their lawsuit contained strong
enough allegations - gleaned from former employees, market
analysis and expert opinion - to survive Nvidia's ( NVDA ) request for
dismissal and proceed to the discovery stage of litigation.
President Joe Biden's administration supported the
shareholders in the case.